And then there are the people who leave the car window too far down…

I will admit to talking to dogs in cars, but usually it is of the nature of “oh, shush, I not coming in your car, see, I’m going to get into mine right now.” And I go about my business and get in my car and go. I don’t understand going up to have a conversation or otherwise antagonize the dog more.

(Okay, I think once I went closer to the car so I could see in, but it was because it looked like the dog was maybe caught or something, so I wanted a different angle. Dog was fine, I went away. Had the dog actually been caught I would’ve gone into the store to have the owner paged. But even then I only got close enough to see. Respect the dog’s space, etc.)

Since this is happening when the dog/car owner is in the store, it is unlikely that they are aware that their dog is being largely protective of the vehicle.

If the cattle dog is an actual working dog, s/he may be more predisposed to being protective of their property.

The only way that this could have been “prevented”, is by you parking in another spot…but how are you supposed to know there is a dog in the vehicle, if they are laying down, or not in view because of car height differences? This is not your fault.

[QUOTE=Calamber;8291003]
You did nothing wrong except talk to and interact with the dog[/QUOTE]

Huh. So the COTH consensus is do not speak to dogs waiting alone in vehicles? I tend to, if I know there’s a dog in there. Shoot, I’m crazy enough that I talk in the parking lots of trials even if I don’t know for sure which cars hold dogs: some do and some don’t. I’ve been scared to death by dogs erupting at the last moment. Timber is now scared to walk in parking lots,this Exploding Car of Canines is so common :no:.

I figure there is no way I’m sneaking by so I’d rather let the dog know a harmless human is in their vicinity, and hope it stays calm, than startle it when I’m almost on top of its car.

[QUOTE=Bicoastal;8295896]
Huh. So the COTH consensus is do not speak to dogs waiting alone in vehicles? I tend to, if I know there’s a dog in there. Shoot, I’m crazy enough that I talk in the parking lots of trials even if I don’t know for sure which cars hold dogs: some do and some don’t. I’ve been scared to death by dogs erupting at the last moment. Timber is now scared to walk in parking lots,this Exploding Car of Canines is so common :no:.

I figure there is no way I’m sneaking by so I’d rather let the dog know a harmless human is in their vicinity, and hope it stays calm, than startle it when I’m almost on top of its car.[/QUOTE]

I tend not to talk to dogs that already look wound up, more so than at all ever? The talking to yourself kind of seems a good idea though. The Exploding Car of Canines is indeed traumatic.

But yes, a dog that is just being loud I will talk to (“jeez, settle down, I’m going”) or a happy dog. One they is already losing it’s little furry mind, nit so much.

Time of year for crazy dogs in the car! Was next to an suv with the windows down and the gas station. Didn’t see the dogs til the guy left to go in to pay. Then Bam!! 2 huge?? dogs growling and snarling. Scared the crap out of me. My dog was in my car, I immediately rolled up my windows and stood trying to block the dogs view of my dog. My dog is a little freaky/shy/aggressive but he looked totally scared. Finished filling up then got in and pulled away before I went in the store.
On a good note—I hit a deer on my way to rally class so my dog was in the car. Car was undriveable. The sheriff and tow truck people were great about the dog. ASked if he was ok… I had the window partly down for air and they were very respectful. MAybe he looked wigged out, he’s a red tri mini aussie with amber eyes. Lookes freaky even when he’s not!

Mine don’t seem to care much about people but it becomes an exploding car if they see a stray cat (they live with 11 of the critters) or a dog goes by. We are often able to watch them for where we are eating inside and people aren’t a problem.

My chessie is crazy over protective of “her” truck. She will NOT jump out, not for anything, I literally can put the tail gate down and tell her to stay and she won’t leave the back of the truck, so leaving isn’t a concern.

Unfortunately, we’ve had to stop taking her places because even parking off by ourselves, people still want to park beside the truck and if she can’t see us, she gets extremely protective and doesn’t want anyone near, especially people of a darker complexion. Now she’ll lunge barking and snarling, but has never so much as tried to bite, and we’ve seen her where she COULD have bit them if she wanted and you could tell it was all for show…in any case we made the decision several years ago that we wouldn’t be bringing her anywhere if one of us couldn’t stay by the vehicle to make sure she doesn’t go terminator on someone lol.

Outside of the truck she’s one of the friendliest dogs you’ll ever see :slight_smile: if in the “quiet protector” way (i.e. when we were building our house she would in turn beg for scraps from the crew, while following my son around and staying between him and the crew members). We’ve noticed she’s gotten worse about the protectiveness as she’s aged and has a bit of deafness, so I do wonder if that’s part of it, she’s almost 10 now and has been a hunting dog her whole life so has been around shotguns and other loud noises.

Dogs are usually very protective of their space in a car. It’s not something you did. They’re in a small, confined space. Their space. And a stranger walking by is considered a violation of it to some dogs.

That dog may have been aggressive but he clearly did not want to bite you, otherwise he would have jumped out of the car and given chase. Seen it done… Then watched the dog jump back in his car.

People can be incredibly careless with dogs in a car.

One year we had three dogs in the back of my Honda civic It was a breezy day for September and we visited a dog-friendly beach, tired out our canine companions with a romp on the strand then elected to grab a bite to eat. We parked on the boardwalk where a restaurant was and sat on the porch on the boardwalk right in front of our car. The car was literally 5 feet away, and we were on the deck supervising them. It was cool out and car was in shade, (~60 degrees) and all windows and the moon roof were open.

We watched multiple people pass by our dogs and they each ignored each other. No problem.

Then we watched a gaggle of teenagers approach the car and our eldest dog said “hark! an intruder approacheth!” - ears swept forward, curly tail a-wagging, all smiles as the teens approached. Our eldest was more inclined to mob you for a cookie than mob you for trespass. We watched, slightly bemused by seeing three dogs looking not unlike Cerberus, pulling their heads through the window @ the teens with inquisitive noses and bright eyes…

But our amusement was short lived as one teen decided to reach into the car to pet the furthest dog, who objected quite clearly to the intrusion. This is the one with the rabid-ole-yeller bay - I never saw a hand retracted so swiftly in my life. What stranger in their right mind places their body part in a strange vehicle with a strange group of dogs?

But anyway, I find if you ignore them and obviously don’t put your hands in their car, they’ll just likely bark and yell at you until you’re off.

FWIW some people have no idea the dog’s behavior in a car… I have had a dog who was the laziest and sweetest thing ever who could give you a murderous stare and stiff upper lip snarl if you walked within 5 feet of his vehicle… and by contrast, my resource-guarding little shithead dog is the biggest beggar for attention in a car… So you never know what your dog’s behavior is to strangers in a car regardless of their behavior outside of it - I find the two are very, very different.

Cattle Dogs tend to be protective and territorial by nature, ours certainly was. And, the car was her territory. I tried to avoid bringing her in the car if I would have to leave the car before we were at our final destination, but if I did have to, I parked on the far end of a row of cars, so one side of the car was not next to another parking space. Then crack only the windows on that side, just a crack. I have a sunroof, so I’d open that for more air circulation and make my stop as quick as possible.

She would not lunge out of the car window, but I was most worried about someone thinking “nice doggie, all dogs love me” and putting their hand in the window…in which case they’d probably come back minus a finger or two.

My BC mix is not like that about the car at all, she does let people pet her through the window. There is the problem about overzealous “rescuers” who will call the police about a dog in a car on a 50 degree day, but fortunately, our PD has common sense about it, they come out, check the situation and if dog is fine, tell the busy body to go on their way.

My neighbor’s Pit cracked me up once. I was on my way to work and didn’t realize that I’d parked right next to my neighbor when I stopped to get coffee on my way. Get out of the car and a big, loud dog starts doing a Cujo act in the car next to me. I turned to look and right then the dog recognized me and his scary demeanor instantly turned to a big, literal, grin. Nothing like a Pit Bull smile ;). It was funny just because of how quickly he changed his face. It wouldn’t have been funny if I were a stranger.