On the observation that âThere is Trouble Right Here In River Cityâ.
The intentions of those of you who feel that as parents, you are duty bound to try to protect all children from sexual predators are honest, correct, and worthy of attention. However, I think that your proposition that it is the duty of USEF to join you in undertaking this task, bears a bit of scrutiny. I think that if you temper emotion with logic, you will discover some issues that bear consideration and restraint. Letâs think about this notion that one of the duties of the USEF is( or should be) to enact and enforce rules denying membership and/or Licensed Official status to any person who has been formally accused of a sexual crime against children.
The USEF is the NGB of the sport of Equestrian in the US. That is what it is responsible for. USEF makes and enforces rules pertaining to that sportâŠrules that affect all exhibitors, not just minors; rules that protect horses; rules that govern the management of horse shows and other equestrian competitions; rules that pertain to High Performance Competition; rules that concern Licensed Officials; and rules that oversee such things as Drug Testing of horses and ponies, and Measurement of animals that compete in classes where they may be classified by height. âEquestrianâ is a sport, but it is also an industry, so there are rules that grant licenses to produce equestrian competitions, and there is a huge department that tries to ensure that competitions are as fair as possible by the enforcement of the USEF rules. Believe meâŠthere are a whole lot of rules!
You are suggesting that USEF should add another layer of regulation to itâs already heaping plateâŠthe regulation against any person who has ever been charged with a sexual crime against a minor.
Seems like a fine idea. But wait! Wasnât there a recent proposal of a similar nature? Wasnât there (last year, I think) a wildly passionate petition to deny membership to any person who has ever been convicted of a crime against a horse.
What happened to that one? It went down in flames, thatâs what happened. And why? For the same reason that this one will likely be passed over by USEF. And that (actually, those) reasons are (drum roll):
- It would take a HUGE separate department of USEF to investigate suspects, take action against them, and then see to it that no such person either attends a show as a spectator, or a trainer, or an exhibitor, or as an Official, Manager, or Staff member....or acts as an employee of a show facility and cleans the bathroom at the fairgrounds, or in ANY way could interact with a child! My guess would be that to cover these costs, membership dues in USEF would hover in the $1000 per year area!
- And let's not forget the costs of defending the litigation that would result from folks who were falsely accused and whose careers and lives were ruined because of that. And the lawsuit against USEF that would surely fly out of the offices of the ACLU. And I bet some folks who had made one big mistake, gone to jail, done their parole, and now were denied the right to work in the only business where they had any qualifications, might seek out the loudest bleeding heart liberal attorney that they could find to "Get" the organization that was denying them the right to earn a living in their area of choice.
- OK....but what about the Judges? (Horse show judges, that is.) The " Do you want your child [U]judged[/U] by a pervert?" argument. I would consider this fact...the people on the show grounds who are barred by rule and protocol from having contact with exhibitors, trainers and parents are...Ta Da... The Judges! Judges are sequestered in tiny booths...in full sight of the whole horse show, and if any judge tried to get chatty, much less rude, with a child exhibitor, a riot would break out. If the object is to insure that a weirdo- could never get a chance to have contact with a child...heck...Give 'em a Judges card! And the same goes for other Officials... Stewards and Course Designers have a ton of things to take care of...and it all goes on in full view of the whole horse show!
- OK...What about Announcers? Yes, Announcers ( and an infamous one at that) live in dark little towers...where they are usually keeping track of the goings on in two or three rings at once, and talking over the mike as fast as their little lips can move. I wouldn't say that it is impossible for an inappropriate remark to be uttered, but in the actual "line of duty", it wouldn't be super easy to get away with. And...Announcers are not Officials. They are Staff, and they are hired by Show Managers. They have NO responsibility to USEF..they don't even have to be members. I can certainly see a point to lobbying against an Announcer to the Managers who hire him, but to the USEF? Why?
- I am a bit unclear here. Some of you say that you are talking to Dateline and trying to get them to come in and expose the Dirty Little Secret of Horse Shows. "AA" Horse Shows...that Sandbox for the Super Rich who flaunt their indescretions in the faces of society and whose denizens endorse Child Molestation and Horse Killings and a bunch of other nasty stuff. But is this "Good For The Sport? Do the underbellies confine their nasty habit to the highest levels of the sport where the rich kids are? Has there never been a creepy little man hanging around 4-H kids, or Little League, or kids in Figure Skating or Gymnastics, Swimming, Tennis...any sport where pubescent, often wealthy, kids in revealing outfits are participating? I don't know the answer to this, but do the NGBs of those sports succeed in keeping child predators totally at bay? Or do the parents and coaches bear some onus in protect their kids? Maybe, those sports have a guy who sneaks around and lops off the balls of any jerk they see acting kinky around the kids.
- And then their are the Trainers! Lots of nasty stuff going on with those guys! But wait! Trainers are totally unregulated by the USEF. Any dweeb with a pair of boots and a gift of gab can "train" your child or your horse for horse show purposes...and charge you a ton for the privilage. And there is NO organization or set of rules or any structure to protect your children or your horses from the bad ones...except the laws of the your State and (in some cases) the Federal Government. FORTUNATELY, this sorry fact is beginning to change, and among the disciplines, there are committees who are, as we speak, developing written standards and practices for trainers. One of these organization is the USHJA, and I hope that in the near future, there will be lists of Trainers who have signed on the line that they will follow these practices, and won't tack on a 200% commission to your horse sale and who know how to administer CPR and things like that. Morals issues are tough, and legal considerations make them tricky. How many trainers would put a check in the box that identified them as a sexual risk to children? Not many, I would venture.
So, what I am saying here is that it comes back to the Parents and to their hired advocates (Trainers and Coaches) to do their best to shield children from sexual predators. Yes, those folks (the predators, that is) are sickos and criminals, however every state has laws that frown severely on such practices. If your child is approached in an inappropriate manner, [U]Call The Cops [/U]fergodsake! They are empowered to throw those guys in jail, and they have the law and their guns to back them up. The USEF is NOT a vigilante committee whose job it is to enforce those laws! The USEF's only jurisdiction is the sport of Equestrian...and that jurisdiction covers horse sports from Local Shows through the Olympics. Personally, I think that's alot of territory, and our membership dollars are spread thin enough in taking care of horse show issues. Strange though it may seem...Horse Shows and Sex Crimes are not one and the same thing!
Some of you may think that my opinions and droll remarks suggest that I endorse and support the habits of sexual predators. PULEEZEâŠthat is not the case! Nothing of that nature is a joke. I have poked some fun at Trainers, Judges, Horse Show Officials and managers, so it is only fair that I now confess that I am personally all of the above.(Though nowadays, I only manage unrated shows.) But I do all the other stuff at USEF shows, so if you want to think that I am guilty of every creepy or money grubbing action that some Trainers, Judges, et al have committedâŠwell, I hate to disappoint you, so flame away if it makes you happy. And, if you really want to make sure that your kid is totally insulated from horrible people, than, I suggest that you prevent them from participation in any sports, artistic activities, or community events. We all know that besides the sports that I mentioned, the Arts are rife with folks who advocate moral laxity, and you never know about those 4-H Leaders!
OmigodâŠI forgot to mention in my prior list of questionable stuff that I do (Trainer, Judge, etc.)âŠI was an Art Major in college!:eek: