Barbaro ~ America's Horse

Why was Barbaro’s suffering prolonged?

We are all saddened by Barbaro’s death. While I agree that every reasonable measure should be taken to save a horse’s life, any horse, I think in Barbaro’s case the Jackson’s went too far by prolonging his suffering months longer than was reasonably humane. And I have to ask–why?

I don’t care what someone wants to spend on treatment. That’s their business. But was it due to public interest/pressure? The media? Maybe it became a medical challenge the vets couldn’t pass up. Or their chance to be a hero against all odds. I don’t think for one minute the powers that be had Barbaro’s interest in mind. The average horse owner would have reached a decsion long ago that enough is enough. Not every horse story has a Seabiscuit ending.

Barbaro was eating, sleeping, and interacting with people. How do you euthanize a horse before it becomes an obvious quality of life issue? When the horse changed and was clearly unhappy, the owners said that’s it.

Everyone knew the odds were long.

I agree with another poster, no decision would have satisfied everyone.

All in all, it is their business.

Cubs, maybe you forgot or never knew that there had been miracles in the past. It wasn’t a compound fracture, so that part of hope had been preserved. Several famous race horses have survived severe breaks and had a reasonable quality of life afterwards.

With all the advances in medical appliances, it was worth a shot for people with money and love. I know if I were seriously injured and there was real hope for recovery, my family wouldn’t pull the plug prematurely.

I just don’t understand how people who 1) aren’t vets 2) don’t know the horse and 3) don’t know the full facts that only Dr. Richardson, his staff and the Jackson’s know; how can these people continue to make such critisism and pass such judgement in this case? It has been stated all along that once Barbaro was in pain, uncomfortable, not eating, etc…that he would be euthanized. This horse was not normal…he did eat, he indicated when he needed his sling and when you looked at his eyes, he was bright eye and alert. Clearly not a horse suffering. The minute that all changed, the Jackson’t and Dr. Richardson wasted no time in making that horrible decision.
The legacy Barbaro leaves will be immeasurable, from the knowledge gained, the money donated and the scholarships awarded, all because of him. My husband says everything happens for a reason…well, perhaps the reason behind this tragedy was to leave such a legacy.

Very well said, Lori T. I couldn’t agree more.

[QUOTE=Cubs;2181138]
I don’t think for one minute[/QUOTE]

Wellll, there’s the problem. :wink:

Try thinking longer.

If you do, and if you follow the constant reports and IF YOU WERE THERE, as people on this list were THERE, you would know that he was going quite well, bright, alert, and happy, all these months. When that changed on Sunday night, he was put down Monday morning.

Tonight, 9pm CNN Larry King Live
Mr & Mrs Jackson

I spoke to someone very close to Barbaro on Friday - without going into detail there no indication of what was about to happen, everything was very positive. I really do not think you were left out on any detail.

Matz soldiers on with Barbaro gone
By JAY PRIVMAN
BOYNTON BEACH, Fla. - Horse training requires working seven days a week, but Tuesday was not a typical work day for Michael Matz. He had to do what he always does, coordinate grooms and hot walkers and exercise riders and assistants to get his 67 horses to and from the track at the Palm Meadows training center. But this was the first day since Barbaro, the colt Matz trained to win last year’s Kentucky Derby, was euthanized.
“It’s hardest when I think and talk about it,” Matz said during a break in training at his barn Tuesday morning. “If I’m working, I don’t have it on my mind. It’s better to keep going.”
“Poor old Michael, he hasn’t slept in months,” Grae Kennedy, one of Matz’s assistants, said while his boss was on the racetrack supervising a set of horses. “You know what Michael’s like. He’s a sensitive guy.”
Two cars parked outside Matz’s barn had bumper stickers that read “Go Barbaro.” The tack room at Matz’s barn had a pair of bouquets on his desk. A copy of Wednesday’s Daily Racing Form, with Barbaro’s obituary on the cover, sat on his desk. An occasional visitor happened by to offer condolences. It all seemed so incongruous to the photo above and to the right of Matz’s desk, which showed Barbaro crossing the wire in the Derby, with all four feet off the ground.
“I guess I just have to look at it that I was lucky enough to have had him once,” Matz said.
“I’ll just have to go out and find another one. But that’ll be pretty darn hard. There’s no telling how good he could have been.”
Matz, 56, has been based at Palm Meadows since November. He spends half the year here, half at the Fair Hill training center in Maryland. Fair Hill is a short ride from the University of Pennsylvania’s New Bolton Center, where Barbaro spent the last 8 1/2 months. Matz said he flew to Maryland to visit Barbaro on Jan. 13. It turned out to be the last time he saw Barbaro.
“He did so well so quickly after the operation, and then in the beginning of November there was talk about getting him out of the hospital,” Matz said. “And then it all went so bad so quick.”
“We all knew this could happen, but we hoped it never would,” said Peter Brette, another Matz assistant who was Barbaro’s exercise rider. “Unfortunately, no one ever saw how good he really could be. We always had said that the Derby was going to be the beginning of him. But it wasn’t meant to be.”
Matz said he got a call early Monday morning from Gretchen Jackson, who owned Barbaro with her husband, Roy.
“She usually doesn’t call that early. She was pretty upset,” Matz said.
Two subsequent calls from Dr. Dean Richardson at New Bolton confirmed Matz’s worst fears, that Barbaro’s condition had deteriorated to the point where he would need to be euthanized.
“Everybody tried their hardest,” Matz said.
Matz said he watched a televised press conference Monday afternoon with Richardson and the Jacksons.
“It looked like they handled it really well,” he said. “I don’t know if I could have done it.”
Matz did, however, have to explain the situation to his two youngest children, Alex and Lucy.
“They wanted to know why we couldn’t do this, couldn’t do that,” he said. “They just didn’t understand all the ramifications.”
Matz was overwhelmed and gratified by the outpouring of emotion directed toward Barbaro from the general public. Although the colt won every one of his races before suffering his catastrophic injuries in the Preakness, his stellar racetrack accomplishments were dwarfed in recent months by his ongoing battle to survive.
“Maybe this was bigger than the Triple Crown,” Matz said. “It’s hard to say.”
Of the 67 horses in Matz’s barn, he has a half-brother to Barbaro named Man in Havana, 3, who is by Quiet American. Waiting in the wings is a yearling full brother to Barbaro who has yet to be named. Matz also trains Round Pond, who won the Breeders’ Cup Distaff and is about a month away from her first start of the year. As good as some of those horses are, or may be, it would be trite to say they will replace Barbaro. Though Barbaro had physically left Matz’s barn the evening of May 20, the emotional void became more pronounced Monday.
“I’ve just got to remember the good things we had and he did,” Matz said. “I guess things happen for a reason. But sometimes you don’t know what that reason is. We just have to group ourselves together and try to go on.”

You can send condolences or comments to New Bolton Center using this link.

http://www.vet.upenn.edu/

Towards the bottom of the page is Send Condolences.

Also good picture of Barbaro and Dr. R.

Didn’t mean that Dr. Richardson suffered from an ego problem, far from it, that’s how he characterized himself early on. Having been around a track or two in my life, we do have some “solid gold hoof vets” here in Kentucky. We are lucky they are in our “back yard” so to speak. Dr Morrison is actually working on my neighbor’s show horse right now, takes a lot to impress me, I’ve seen some of the best, let me just say, I’m impressed with his work and I certainly understand why they called him in. As to why they waited, I’m not sure, but I can only speculate that the first problem obviously his right leg, laminitis in the left hind was almost certainly going to be an issue at some point, and when it got to the point when some sort of ortho shoe/device was necessary, they went to the go to guy. When it gets to that level, everything is specialized, I’m sure his nutrition and everything were minutely scrutinized. Didn’t mean your guy isn’t good, but I do have that Kentucky bias…

Michael is truly an amazing guy - many people know how much he loved Barbaro, very few know that every horse in his barn receives the same love and attention Barbaro got - Michael knows every horse in his barn personally, spends time with them, and puts their needs before his! Michael and his staff are wonderful, and I am sure together with their horses they will turn this tragedy into something positive.

A moving tribue to Barbaro http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tz5xzK4q6Xw

from today’s NY Daily News:

“I hope we can turn our love into an energy that supports horses throughout the world,” Gretchen Jackson said. “One fan of Barbaro said to me this afternoon that she thought Barbaro’s thoughts were, ‘Please finish these unfinished tasks of mine, and therefore I will comfort you.’”

Today is the first time in about 7 months that I am not lighting my four candles (one for each of my horses) for Barbaro. Seems weird, seems empty. But I guess that is how many of us feel.

Thank you for all of your time and effort, Virginia Bred. I feel that you have been a special part of my life for the last 8 months. The Big Guy connected us all. That was one of his gifts. :slight_smile:

bad bad larry king. well done Jacksons and Dr Richardson.

Did anyone besides me turn off larry king before they had to listen to Bo Derek and the PETA PITAs?

Bo Derek was actually very good and informed. She is likes racing and regularly attends.

[QUOTE=Lori T;2181189]
I just don’t understand how people who 1) aren’t vets 2) don’t know the horse and 3) don’t know the full facts that only Dr. Richardson, his staff and the Jackson’s know; how can these people continue to make such critisism and pass such judgement in this case? It has been stated all along that once Barbaro was in pain, uncomfortable, not eating, etc…that he would be euthanized. This horse was not normal…he did eat, he indicated when he needed his sling and when you looked at his eyes, he was bright eye and alert. Clearly not a horse suffering. The minute that all changed, the Jackson’t and Dr. Richardson wasted no time in making that horrible decision.
The legacy Barbaro leaves will be immeasurable, from the knowledge gained, the money donated and the scholarships awarded, all because of him. My husband says everything happens for a reason…well, perhaps the reason behind this tragedy was to leave such a legacy.[/QUOTE]

Exactly, well said. There must be many omnipresent people among us. :wink:

I did

I did.