I bought a pair of paddock boots form Ariat in 2010 and they’re still going strong. I condition them every two weeks and use them 4-6 days a week depending on the week, all day. But I know people at my barn that bought them this year and had them wear out within 6 months. I always love Ariats for the price.
Best Purchases:
Pessoa AO Saddle. It’s not a super expensive saddle and it can be had for $1,100 used if you look (I got it very dried out for $750 used from a friend). But this thing is comfy and my riding position improved a TON in it compared to the other saddles I was riding in. I like it better than the Stubben Siegfried.
Passier Lederbalsam. This works miracles on most leather I work it into.
Things that impressed/surprised me but aren’t the “best best” would probably be The Tailored Sportsman breech (or the low rise version of it) because it’s so durable and looks great, Thinline pads, Back on Track pads, Iridion Riding Tights, and Roeckl Chester Gloves.
Worst:
Prestige Split-End Girth. This thing consistently rubbed the skin until it was raw/irritated on multiple horses, even when it was done loosely. Not a single horse was comfortable in it.
Weatherbeeta Genero. We got a bunch of these as backups to blanket horses while their blankets were out being washed. Within a month half of the buckles, loops, end snaps, etc were completely broken and ripped off on every single one. Never seen that happen with a blanket before.
Other mentions for worst would be… Roeckl Winter gloves (they fail to keep me warm even in 35 degree weather). Cheaper Ariat breeches of any kind (they make my butt look like someone stuffed a pillow down there, and they retain stains even after being washed and bleached to holy hell). 99% of cheap fleece half pads (I will forever use sheepskin).