Yep, this is what I did. I liked the renegades just fine. Used them on the hind feet of my retired horse and trusted them on steep rutted paths in the GA mountains, not to mention crossing the Etowah and other water/mud crossings. He’s no longer with us, but the new (way too young) retiree uses them on his bare front feet if he has an abscess or an owie moment, so they still get used.
I switched to the scoots because the new pony (Fjord )had umm, significantly larger feet than the 16’3 TB LOL, so new boots were needed and I liked how these looked (tightening the renegades was not my favorite task). Because it is a Fjord I only need them for days where I must do fitness work and the road has been freshly grated and the gravel is not yet packed down. That’s only been a handful of times in the last 2 years, but they have been fine for those times and I did give them a test run on the trails where they worked fine.
But again, what really matters is that they fit. But in any event, I would prefer a boot with an open back so it drains water/mud rather than accumulate it!