[QUOTE=spacytracy;6160244]
Hey, does anyone get Practical Horseman? I was leafing through it the other day and they have an article on equitation, and describes the ideal equitation over fences, but then shows a photo of a Maclay rider (I think) with what I would describe as less than ideal equitation. I guess my reasoning for scrutinizing is, I want to know what’s right! And I still cannot figure out what is acceptable. To me, having your butt a foot out of the saddle and basically on the pommel is incorrect, but this rider did. Now, camera tricks plays into it as well, but…many of the “winning” riders I see have this type of riding style. I just don’t get it.[/QUOTE]
Spacy: What’s nice about equitation, but also frustrating, is that it must first and foremost be effective. We can describe the “perfect” position, but it also requires the “perfect” horse for that specific rider’s conformation to be “ideal.”
There’s actually a good explanation of this in George Morris’ “Hunt Seat Equitation” Where he explains that the horse’s conformation and jumping style influence the overall picture of horse and rider. I think he used Christy Conard and her horse Night Moves to explain that a horse who jumps upright (and a lot of modern equitation horses do, because it flattens the jump and makes it easier to ride) will break up the lines a little bit as he jumps up into the rider versus down and away from the rider like a hunter might.
Another example of a horse who jumps like this is Brianne Goutal’s Logan, seen here: http://www.nhs2011.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/000673.jpg
because he is jumping up into her, and she is blessed with some length of leg, the upper body is naturally close to the horse and the line breaks up from hand to mouth, and the same with the leg position which counter balances.
Here’s the same rider, same horse, showing a more traditional jump and thus, more classic equitation:
http://www.floridahorse.com/images/2004wef/goutalPB31404.jpg
Still the long release which is common today, but otherwise, very correct, but obviously influenced by the horse’s jumping style.