Chiro vs massage vs acupuncture?

[Bogie]

[QUOTE=Andean Echo;8277846]
It seems to me that when people rave about great chiropractors, they’re actually raving about great massage therapists. I have yet to be convinced that any bone-manipulation is actually occurring. So if you’re seeing great benefits from chiropractic care, by all means do not let anything stop you from utilizing such care (including me)! But (not that it really matters ;)) just know that I think the benefits are actually coming from the massage of the muscles, not manipulation of the skeleton.[/QUOTE]

My personal experience is the same. When I was dealing with a pinched nerve I saw chiropractors and had some temporary relief. It wasn’t until I found a very good massage therapist that it resolved.

I do not use chiropractors on my horse. I’m sure there are some good ones, but I’ve encountered too many bad ones. My saddle fitter does body work so I have him do both. I also use some of Jim Masterson’s techniques keep apprised of where my horses are holding tension and to help them release it.

I have my saddles fit twice a year and am a big believer that it helps to keep my horses comfortable

[MtnDrmz]

We have used not only these three things on our horses, but also reiki, cranio sacral (spelling?) and different energy work. Love the chiro and massage, and yes you really have to get a good one who knows horses, and they should be done together for better results. Don’t know what area you are in, but we have a wonderful lady that works on our barn and has literally done wonders for some
Of our horses.

Some people may discount more alternative treatments, but the way I look at it, horses don’t know what is supposed to work or not. They just respond. So if it works for your horse, it works! Also, some horses respond better to different techniques and treatments so if you try one that doesn’t make a difference, it may just be that you need a different touch.

[aascvt]

I too am doubtful about chiro and acupuncture due to the overwhelming lack of evidence to suggest that they are worthwhile modalities to treat back pain. It is great that you had a vet come out. Did he/she take radiographs of the back? Things that i have seen to be more effective are mesotherpy, injecting the dorsal spinous processes IF there are changes on radiographs, and changing the horses’ exercise program to strengthen the back muscles as much as possible. Robaxin can also be helpful for short periods of time while allowing other treatments to take hold. Good luck…