DSLD "diagnosis" in young, lame horse -- UPDATE post 130, he's gone

J-Lu, I am glad you posted that. I found it very informative, and have sent it, and the PM to me, to my vet.

I also looked up Desmitis., and I can see that it and DSLD present with very similar symptoms.

Somewhere, I read that Mueller does not believe in stall rest.

Here is the PM that J-Lu sent to me because the questions/responses were addressing Goober’s (and my vet’s problems with getting a sufficient sample) issues:

  • 1. Dr. Mueller, a vet surgeon, said he almost never sees DSLD without some kind of other trauma, because the horses are usually ridden and sport horses have a lot of wear and tear. Normal wear and tear will create scar tissue, and most horses who develop DSLD have been ridden and are often treated for something else (which may mask the pain) along the way. Horses with true DSLD will continue to decline, though.
    2. He said that there is no pattern to legs developing DSLD, and by the time HE seems them (confirmed by the NC State vets), they are usually bad off because they didn't respond to the primary vet's treatments. Mostly it's bilateral or involving all 4. Mostly. But there's there's a researcher who suggest that it first shows up in hocks (upper collateral ligaments) and the horse adjusts itsself to compensate, hastening the degradation of the suspensories. Some horses, such as Friesians, with DSLD have significant collagen degradation in their aorta and are prone to aneurysms. Why in that breed? They don't know/ They study Peruvian Pasos mainly because a breeder donated many of their horses to U of GA, but they stated several times that a comparison between breeds is needed.Dr. Halpern is trying to do some genetic work, but they can only compare gene sequences to the published horse genome, and she doesn't know what breed that is (I asked her). Genes might be different in different breeds, and the breeding pool for some breeds is especially global. They can only state "facts" on horses they have seen/studied, which isn't a lot. They said they know owners and vets can be very frustrated because they cannot give a yes/no answer and some vets go to the nuchal ligament because they run out of options. One vet from NC state said he has seen a couple of cases in warmbloods over the years, but he has seen pretty much as many in the last 5 years. They talked about the fact they don't know why this is. It is, however, degenerative, and will eventually affect the horse.
    
    3. Dr. Mueller gave a visual tutorial, as part of his presentation, on how to correctly biopsy the nuchal ligament. He said he gets samples ALL THE TIME that aren't the ligament but are just fat, or not enough ligament. Some vets try to use a needle, some try to take a punch biopsy. These methods just don't work well. Many vets go too high towards the crest and miss the nuchal ligament completely. He recommends a vertical incision (~3 inches) , at the crease of the crest muscle, dissecting down to find it, and clamping a small area with two Kelley hemostats, and cutting just cranial and just dorsal so that the hemostats are attached to it He does a simple suture and a shot of penicillin, and the wound heals well. He does it on the side the mane falls on. He showed examples, his incision site is barely noticeable. He is happy to talk to vets and owners about it all, and guide vets to get a proper sample. He stressed, stressed that the biopsy is going to be inconclusive and subjective, and has to be considered with the rest of the clinical evidence.
    
4 Likes

Is your horses’ injury new? I know that some vets do not want too much moving around when the injury is “fresh”. For example, friends horse had a very serious injury of something going down into the hoof (can’t remember what at the moment) and for the first 2-3 weeks the horse was only hand grazed for 10 minutes twice daily until the swelling etc was under control and then they started with short hand walks and increased over time.

I had one vet clinic that did the MRI tell me they wanted the horse hand walking 3 times for 20 minutes each day from the beginning. Clinic he went to for rehab would not do that, said it was way too much to soon. I agreed with them but insisted later on that he do more hand walking than the other horses at the clinic because that was the best thing for my horse. Talk to as many people as you can about it and decide what is best for your horse. It is confusing and frustrating.

Luckily I trust my home vet so much. He hasn’t steered me wrong yet and seems to inherently know what will work best for my big silly horse. He picks up on things that others missed (he’s been around the block a few times)or weren’t concerned about but ended up being a big deal for my horse.

I think I’ve missed a bunch in your posts. Any chance you could post in chronological bullets what has gone on with your horse? Might help people help you more.

Hang in. I know how frustrating it can be. Trust me.

1 Like

Thanks! :slight_smile: I’m hanging in. “Talk to as many people as you can about it and decide what is best for your horse. It is confusing and frustrating.” << Makes sense, although sometimes I think I have talked to too many people already!

To answer your questions, the horse’s injury is probably not new since he went lame on the left front in mid-October (another reason I’m questioning shockwave–seems like it’s less useful when the injury isn’t as fresh). Here’s a chronology:

Mid-October: horse goes lame on LF; regular farm vet gets positive response to hoof testers and says it’s sole bruising so I pack feet and administer Previcox for 10 days

Early November: horse still isn’t right so I take him to hospital; first choice of vet isn’t available so I see someone else; turns out horse is also 2/5 lame on LH but she believes that’s most likely compensation for 3/5 lameness on LF; x-rays of both front feet show nothing of great interest except for coffin joint arthritis in LF so we inject coffin joint to see if that makes a difference; she says next step is MRI and I think :eek:; I’ve not had a lame horse since MRIs became common so it feels like a big jump to me

Late November: no improvement from coffin joint injection so I see my first choice of vet, who is now available; he believes the LF is compensatory for the LH rather than the other way around; based on blocking, palpation, and horse’s conformation (long hind pasterns) he diagnoses hind proximal suspensory desmitis and recommends a neurectomy; again I think :eek: because this sounds so extreme; I also start wondering about DSLD but vet says he wouldn’t worry about that as he believes my horse’s issues are conformational only

Early December: we go through with bilateral hind neurectomies; I now regret this but I had a lot of faith in this vet and based on my research, hind PSD doesn’t often improve with rest alone; I had a thread on this too, here: https://www.chronofhorse.com/forum/forum/discussion-forums/horse-care/9940453-neurectomy-for-suspensories-in-performance-horse-why-is-this-okay

Late Jan: after the month of stall rest and a month of small paddock turnout post-surgery, horse is still lame to varying degrees on LF, LH, and RH :cry:; I’m about to go out of town for a month so vet endorses Dr. Green until I return and we can further diagnose; vet is not optimistic about horse’s chances of returning to soundness due to his long hind pasterns, which makes me super depressed as he is only 5 and a perfect riding horse (other than being lame, ha) whom I was hoping would be my next Grand Prix (dressage) horse

Mid-March: decide to get second opinion; first choice of second opinion vet is unavailable so I see someone else; she agrees with last vet about conformational limitations (long hind pasterns); says MRI is next step to diagnose LF; no real opinion on DSLD; this vet’s colleague who was there also sees horse for a few minutes and is certain he has DSLD just from looking at him (if only diagnosis were that easy! :rolleyes:) so I schedule nuchal ligament biopsy

Mid-April: first choice of second opinion vet unexpectedly becomes available so I see him; agrees with other vets about conformational limitations and that MRI is next step for LF; I schedule MRI and then a few days before get the “positive” nuchal ligament biopsy result that precipitates this thread; more tears and anguish

Late-April: decide to go through with MRI anyway, given the dubious nature of the biopsy, and horse is diagnosed with moderate desmitis of the lateral collateral ligament of the coffin joint; we have a diagnosis, yay! (really wish I had just done the damn MRI back in Nov when the first vet suggested it, would have saved me a lot of time and money and stress)

Now: since 5 months of continued turnout with 1 month of stall rest in the middle didn’t bring any improvement, horse is now on stall rest and getting shockwave; plan is to re-evaluate after three sessions of shockwave and at that point to consider more diagnostics for the LH; I definitely feel more at peace now that we have a plan even though I’m not sure shockwave is the best choice

1 Like

Sounds like Dr. Halper may need to speak with Dr. Valberg about the genetic sequencing stuff. So far, Valberg has only identified the PSSM type 1 gene, but she is trying to make a correlation with type 2 and MFM which requires looking at warmbloods. I think her biggest issue right now is small n size as well. Both there and with DSLD I think we may not be looking at a single gene mutation but perhaps a combination of markers. It’s complicated stuff even with a large pool of data.

I was working on some patent applications like a decade ago where the company was trying to correlate various single nucleotide polymorphisms with propensity for various cardiovascular diseases. It was complicated stuff.

What’s hard with something degenerative like DSLD is we will likely need a combination of tests because I doubt there’s going to be one smoking gun kind of a gene correlation. So, we’ll have a genetic propensity for the disease plus we’ll need a biopsy that is also suggestive of the disease all in conjunction with clinical signs. It sounds to me like this is what Valberg is hoping to get to PSSM type 2 and MFM, especially MFM, which appears to have the least reliable biopsy results, also dependent on the horse’s age.

3 Likes

Question: do the lesions from a DSLD horse ever begin to heal? Or does damage continue to get worse On a consistent basis?
Goobs has significant “healing” (filling in the torn area with scar tissue) since the first sonogram was taken last October. I am hoping
that once the scar tissue totally fills in the void, Goobs might be allowed to be walked under tack. Am I too hopefull in my presumtion?

typing on my cell phone. pls forgive typos

So, given what I’ve learned about the state of knowledge/research on this disease and how much disagreement there is, I don’t know if I would accept this all as fact but my understanding is that the injured areas fill in with cartilage rather than normal tissue.

“Other research has proposed that horses with DSLD have an abnormal healing process in the suspensory ligaments. Wear and tear associated with normal regular exercise causes small ‘microtraumas’ that occur in the suspensory ligaments. Normal horses produce more cells that lay down additional collagen fibers to repair the ligament. In horses with DSLD, these cells do not lay down collagen, but convert to a type of cell that produces cartilage instead. This abnormal tissue within the ligaments does not allow it to stretch and extend normally, so breakdown occurs.” http://www.ckequinehospital.com/page…-Desmitis-DSLD

“Horses affected with DSLD have an abnormal healing response. Regardless of the causes of the injury or strain, the damaged tissue heals with cartilage instead of collagen. Fibroblasts defect and become chondrocytes and the ligament is unable to restore itself to normal tissue strength.” http://www.equipodiatry.com/dsld.htm

This suggests that it should look different on ultrasound than healing tissue: “The finding of a characteristic hyperechoic (white) pattern in the suspensory, rather than the hypoechoic (dark holes) usually seen with traumatic injuries.” https://www.equisearch.com/HorseJour…pensory-damage (not the most scientific reference, seems to be a product plug)

Maybe ask Kent Allen if he can explain to your vet how to distinguish between normal healing and DSLD cartilage fill-in?

How’s Goober’s neck doing BTW?

1 Like

Thanks for the great history Libby2563.

Sorry you’ve had such a run around. That totally sucks. When my vet said there was an injury in the foot I decided to immediately take him for a standing MRI because I just didn’t want to spend the time and money dicking around with other possibilities and boy am I glad I did because we wouldn’t have known the severity of his injuries or that he had done damage to three separate areas. I opted for the standing MRI even though it was further away and more expensive because my horse would be THE horse that half killed himself coming out of the full sedation…that’s how he rolls.

For some of these injuries, controlled movement really is important. My horse was on stall rest for 6 months with progressive hand walking only and then under saddle walking starting month 7. It was another 6 months of really slow and steady under saddle work to get him back to walk/trot/canter work and then we started turn out. I know this is not necessarily the norm but it was the right thing for my horse in this situation. He was sound. They told me he had a 30% chance but we did it.

Vets opted to not inject anything because of the location of my horses injuries and to go with shock wave on all three injured areas. He also had daily Theraplate sessions and loved those.

At least you have something to work on now. :slight_smile: Keep truckin’!

1 Like

Wouldn’t scar tissue also tend to look whitish on ultrasound? More calcified tissue? It at least wouldn’t look like dark holes any longer.

1 Like

LOL. From p1 on, we have all learned so much that we are beginning to sound like vets. Probably the only positive result from DSLD or just plain old Desmitis.

I just invited a poster to come on over. Her horse has an avulsion fracture and a damaged sesamoid.

G’s neck is finally improving. He will always have a big dent there, but healing is good, so I will take what I can get.

PS: How do I get a photo from a Samsung cell phone to show up on COTH?

PPS: G has had 2 shockwave sessions. After the 3rd one next week we are going to do another ultra sound. It will be interesting to see. After #1 he stood on that hind leg for several days until he started resting it again… And after #2, he has looked almost normal standing on all 4 legs for over a week. I cannot wait to see how he is after #3.

3 Likes

Yay!!! Sounds like progress on two fronts. I’m happy for you! You’re owed some good news.

Just to add to the DSLD info on this thread, I wanted to report that I consulted Dr. Sabrina Brounts at University of Wisconsin who is collecting DNA samples for a genetic study on DSLD. To diagnose DSLD they consider ultrasounds of all four suspensory ligaments, a clinical lameness exam, and the nuchal ligament biopsy. I told her my horse’s diagnosis was less than solid but I wanted to contribute to the study if possible, so she looked at all his records and said:

“I can totally understand the confusion amongst all the veterinarians after going through the medical records. I saw that Dr. Halper suggests DSLD; however looking at the horse in the videos and the pictures, your horse does not act like a DSLD horse. The fetlocks in the hind are not that far dropped and I do not see any thickening as best as I can see.”

Lord Helpus, she may be able to answer your question about how the tissues of a DSLD horse heal and how that would appear on ultrasound. She offered to work with my local vet if I wanted to do the full ultrasound exam (not in the cards financially right now but good to know for the future).

2 Likes

Libby, How did you find Dr. Brounts? She sounds like someone I should talk to.

I am having trouble defining the mechanism that decides to create scar tissue instead of ligimentous (sp?) tissue. I asked Dr. Google to help. He (she?) found this site.

https://www.valleyvet.com/Library/lib_36492_-Product_Information.pdf

There is no author or date, and it sounds like he is promoting his own invention. But, aside from that, I am beginning to understand the process.

Has anyone ever heard of his product?

1 Like

I’ve heard of his product but the list of ingredients are vague and it’s horribly expensive!

Somebody upthread linked to the genetic study she’s running at U of Wisconsin and I emailed her to offer my horse’s DNA: https://uwveterinarycare.wisc.edu/cl…s/large-animal. I would definitely email her. She’s been very kind and approachable and she clearly has advanced knowledge of diagnostic protocols.

Here’s a study she co-authored: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/art…1/#!po=76.5487

1 Like

Update: re-check after a month of rest and two shockwave sessions has shown improvement in LF lameness from 3.5 to 2.5, yay! Bad news is his LH is still lame. Blocking and ultrasounds diagnosed bilateral hind insertional desmopathy of the medial suspensory branches. Sigh…

The interesting thing is that the suspensories looked otherwise normal on ultrasound, no unusual fiber pattern or signs of DSLD. Ultrasound isn’t 100% reliable for diagnosis or course but I’m taking it as a good sign.

1 Like

Update: re-check after 14 weeks of stall rest, 3 shockwave sessions on the collateral ligament, and 1 shockwave session on the hind suspensories–still 2.5 / 5 lame on the LF, just the same as he was in late May. :cry: I cannot believe that with all my time, work, and money he has not improved at all in 2+ months. I am pretty crushed. I was hoping he had continued to improve 1 grade/month or /shockwave and would be almost sound now.

The really weird thing is that when the vet blocked specifically the area of the lateral collateral ligament, that did NOT resolve his lameness AT ALL. So it seems possible that the collateral ligament has in fact healed but he is still just as lame. This time it blocked to the coffin joint. We know there’s some arthritis there (detected on x-rays and MRI) so the plan is to inject that joint with HA and steroids, then reevaluate 2 weeks later. Of course we couldn’t inject yesterday since it had just been blocked, and the soonest I can get it done is next Wed.

Meanwhile he still also becomes 1/5 on the LH when the LF is blocked. His ultrasounds from May mysteriously vanished when the machine crashed right after we left, so I was anxious to get new ones yesterday. I want to send them to someone who looks at a lot of DSLD ultrasounds. This time one of the two vets who saw the images did say she thought the fiber pattern disruption was characteristic of early DSLD (whereas last time the main vet said it wasn’t). This is so very confusing.

I think I am reaching the end of my options for this horse, which is really sad because I do think he’s quite special. He has good movement and talent for dressage, but more importantly he also has the most amazing brain. Super brave, curious, willing, and trainable. I loved riding him. Now I am giving up hope that I ever will again. I also don’t see myself buying another expensive or “forever” horse anytime soon (though I did recently buy a cheap project pony who is super cute and helping to distract me from my woes). It’s just too crushing when things go wrong.

Hi Libby, I just wanted to let you know that I feel your pain. Try to hang in. I know how hard and frustrating it can be.

It takes a REALLY, REALLY LONG time…

I rehabbed my big guy from a torn DDFT at P2 and navicular, medial collateral and distal sesamoid injuries on his front right. As far as I know the injury occurred mid September a couple of years ago but hind sight being what it is, I think the DDFT might have been pretty minor before the big paddock freak out that blew it up and caused the other injuries. We’d had a slight on and off RF issue before that we were looking into.

Most of the vets involved gave him a 15-35% chance of regaining soundness but I love this guy in a very unhealthy way so I had to try anyway.

He was on stall rest with 10 minutes hand walking for the first month and a half and then 20 minutes and then up to 30 minutes. He had a bunch of shock wave treatments at all three locations and also was on a Theraplate every day for 30 minutes. He also had regular massage therapy to help keep muscle atrophy at bay and help with boredom.

I redid the MRI in March (6 months after injury) to check and he was doing fantastic (healing really well but not completely) and we started tack walking at the beginning of April and I brought him home at the end of April. His feet were not balanced properly so this caused us another 6 week set back and then we started with 2 minutes of trot around June and by the end of September we were walk/trot/canter and going to start lateral work and poles, sound!!! Then we had another incident that involved extensive rehab but nothing to do with those injuries…basically been rehabbing this guy for 5 years…sigh. I have to keep trying. He feels like home when I sit on him.

Hi Libby! I cannot reply to your last PM. My computer will not scroll down far enough to click on “Post”.

Sooner or later you will have to reach the end of testing. The current issue is “when”? If he cannot even maintain his current level of unsoundness when kept on limited freedom, you might as well see what happens when he lives in a field. The constant motion of weight bearing on his bad leg actually made Goober better.

[Without highjacking Libby’s thread — Goobs is doing quite well. Last week he started walking under tack, and will be doing that for 3 months — to strengthen his hind legs — before trying to trot.]

Point being: if your boy is ever going to improve, and if he has not made a significant improvement on limited t/o, then you might as well try full turnout to see of strengthening his muscles/ligaments helps.

If you end up having to choose among #1-5, I would (and have) gone with your last choice. Remember – horses live in the moment; they have no concept of ‘the future’. So worrying about whether to euthanize or euthanize and then necropsy makes no never mind to him. Anything that vets can learn about DSLD (or what they think might be DSLD but isn’t) can help people in the future who have to make these decisions.

Tons of good thoughts coming your way.

PS: It seems to me that a tentative diagnosis of DSLD does not come from all the tests, but from the horse’s conformation. Goobs does have a dropped fetlock on his LH, but that is his only bad leg/foot. Since DSLD usually appears on bilateral or quadrilateral legs, Goober’s lameness on only his LH gave us hope. And t/o has helped his dropped pastern lift somewhat, so he is sometimes even weight bearing on that leg.

I spent over $1000 on “the boom-boom” machine with no additional positive results. So far that is the only test is wish I had not wasted money on.

PPS: G still has an open, pussy hole in his neck…FINALLY a second sample was taken to ONCE AGAIN see what the puss is. I am upset that we are 4? - 5? months out and his neck is the same.

Blah. Coffin joint injection is on Wed. We’re going to a different vet (because she’s much closer; these vets collaborate regularly) and I’m curious to hear her opinion on the new developments. Her practice seems to see a lot more DSLD too so maybe she’ll have thoughts on the ultrasounds.

I spent some time the other day looking for a place where he could have a year of Dr. Green (my 3 acres won’t hold up to that) but I still have to do some thinking about whether it’s fair/safe to ship him a couple hours away and leave him in a stranger’s care. For months 1-2 and 5-6 of his lameness, he was on regular turnout so it’s not like movement hasn’t had any chance to help. Maybe his collateral ligament needed to heal first though.

This is bananas! My guy’s hole healed completely within about 3 weeks and now that the hair has grown back it’s just a small dent. I hope you can figure out what’s going on there.

Well, the vet who injected the coffin joint today does not seem at all concerned that he hasn’t improved over the past 2 months and didn’t put much stock in the supposedly-collateral-ligament specific block. Both of these vets are extremely well-regarded. It’s frustrating that I can’t get a clear answer for anything with this horse.