Today I was able to try the Fager Lilly single-jointed bar relief snaffle on Bingo, who 99% of the time is super resistant to halting hand aids (and seat halting aids and leg halting aids too, he just wants to keep going to the gate.)
My riding teacher liked how this bit looked better than the Fanny and Frida tongue relief bits I had tried on Bingo.
My ride did not start off showing much positive improvement, he was just as resistant to all halting aids as with all other bits. He took contact fine and he kept his mouth a little quieter (his gaping was not as wide.)
Towards the end of my lesson I decided to try stopping while headed to the gate, the time (end of the lesson) and place he has been the most resistant to stopping short of planting his breast against the gate.
My halting aids are alternating tweaks of my fingers, first one side as the hind leg comes forward alternating with the other side as that hind leg comes forward. When I asked him to halt going toward the gate I had NO HOPE of him stopping at all.
Guess what, he stopped after my second rein tweak, instead of six sets of tweaks or so.
My mouth literally fell open, this was totally unexpected, and my riding teacher was also pleased. Then I told him to walk again, and around a third of the way down the ring I gave another set of alternating tweaks, and he stopped again, immediately with no arguments, no “I don’t wanna stop” or heavy gaping.
This is a HUGE improvement for this horse, and it took only a half-hour ride. The improvement was not immediate, I had asked him to stop before several places in the ring with his usual reluctance to stop. Then, all of a sudden, OBEDIENCE!
My tentative conclusion is that Bingo seems to prefer the bar relief bit to the tongue relief bit. I never got a quick stop out of him in the five weeks I rode him in the Fager tongue relief bits.
Considering that Cider’s contact became steadier in this bit I am coming to the conclusion that, for older horses who had less than ideal riding in the previous decades, this bar relief bit is seen as an improvement over all the other bits I’ve tried on these horses (normal stainless steel & titanium bits, and the Wellep stainless steel bit.)