For everyone complaining of “permanent shrinkage”: http://chapinserts.com/
I ditto someone else’s advice that Kat should borrow some full chaps before taking the plunge. Kat, you may not like them. Or you may not find them to be the winter-riding panacea that you’re imagining. And I say this as someone who owns and loves my ProChaps Full Chaps, and I live in Ohio too. But my full chaps only get pulled out when Under Armour + Wind Pro fleece breeches aren’t cutting it. And that’s basically just 15 degrees or less with a lot of wind.
If you were hoping they’d keep you warm during chores or while traipsing through muddy paddocks, consider the cleaning implications of traipsing through mud and muck in suede or a full leg of leather. Or if you don’t plan to don your full chaps until right before you ride, consider the implications of putting them on/off repeatedly in cold weather. Does your barn have a heated area where you can do this? If not, you may find yourself in the cold, wrestling with leather or suede (which tends to be less flexible in the cold), possibly/probably with your gloves off, wrangling with a cold metal zipper. Not as glamorous as it sounds.
Cleaning suede = not fun. Cleaning smooth leather = okay I guess, but it’s one more piece of leather to clean during the cold season.
Your butt might still be cold.
As soon as you purchase a lovely pair of full chaps, you will catch a ride on a horse whose saddle is delicate calfskin that can’t cope with the friction from the full chaps.
If you misjudge the sizing, full chaps–especially custom ones–are not an easy resell.
As others have mentioned, not everyone is comfortable in full chaps.
The price of additional grip and warmth all the way up your thigh = additional bulk. It’s an acquired taste.
As others have mentioned, you might grow out of them.
Just some food for thought.