Horse trailer falls apart in wreck on highway

Ok cool. Thanks!

Honestly ā€¦ does anyone else think a person who has hauled twice would be adept on a highway ? Trailering is a skill. It takes reps. At easier conditions. With perfect equipment. Live animals are far different than hauling anything else

6 Likes

The rental place had a duty to set her up for success. Pulling a little BP isnā€™t a huge deal.

3 Likes

Her webpage said she just purchased the ball. I wonder if it was the right size. No way knowing and Iā€™m not going to ask as they are in shock and that would be awful to find out that the got a ball that was too small. She did say it was a 2 5/16 coupler.

There is also someone who make interesting points:



Sadly, sounds like a complete mess and who knows what the actual cause was. I think having the trailer explode like that saved the horseā€™s lives though.

Edit to add: I blew up a picture of the ball and itā€™s the correct size but there seems to be rub marks on it. So who knows. It might be the trailer manufactureā€™s fault like the above says.

4 Likes

Theres a horrifying video
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/m8RDCKQY8cFscvwE/

3 Likes

Disagree but thank you for your reply

Whoa. That is scary.

1 Like

On my first GN, the way the chains were attached it made sense to me to cross them. On my current one, they attach from the same point so crossing isnā€™t physically possible. But thinking about it now, I think that having the chains not crossed would be more stable.

She does have a multi ball hitch on. Hitch is straight, not a drop, that does put some extra stress on the trailer axle.

Depends entirely on the truck though. My '11 Sierra requires a rise hitch. Definitely more common to need a drop hitch but not necessarily always the case.

Just another piece of the puzzle to consider.

This appears to be a two horse straight load, and it had 2 horses in it. Based on the photos of the wreck, it appears to be this model (but a 2017):

2023 New Shadow 2 Horse KingMate Straight Load 12 at Kingdom Horse Trailers Serving the Equestrian Community Nationwide, MD, IID 21910180

You canā€™t get the axles much more back than that.

The wreck is in a construction zone. Maybe thereā€™s something to that, but likely not. Think of how many other nearly identical trailers went through this area without issue.

Trailer driver said the truck is a 2019 Chevy 1500. Almost guaranteed that should have been on some sort of drop hitch. Everything after about 2008 started with the bigger and bigger, higher and higher truck trend you see today.

2019 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Price, Value, Depreciation & Reviews | Kelley Blue Book

Iā€™m going to guess based on the nicks you can see on the ball and the nicks you can see on the coupler, that this trailer was riding VERY nose high, and that contributed substantially to it disconnecting. Not enough tongue weight, and way-off angle of ball and coupler.

10 Likes

I just think of the person I used to see towing into where I trail ride with a stock trailer tilted back at almost a 10-degree angle from their truckā€¦ poor horses had to ride with all their weight on their back legs, plus the fact it could come off an anytime. Ugh. Havenā€™t seen them in a few years, maybe they stopped riding.

3 Likes

Itā€™s one of the reasons I sold the little featherlite I had. I have an 8" drop and it was STILL nose high. I wonā€™t drop lower than that without adding stabilizing struts to the hitch, and I didnā€™t want to do that - so the trailer went bye-bye.

2 Likes

I have a '80ā€™s two horse Bison with dressing room. Nice and heavy. Axels back right under the horses. With a drop hitch. I donā€™t tow too far so I donā€™t care about the gas mileage. I didnā€™t want a newer aluminum trailer - I wanted to know I had something solid.

Plus, my husband welds, so the frame has already been reinforced :slight_smile: much to his complaining about wanting to work on his cars LOL! Heā€™s been towing race cars for over 50 years.

1 Like

Last thing - truck driver says the truck had the tow package. The tow package for this truck does not appear to include a brake controller, from the specs I could look up.

If they did not have one installed aftermarket (they did not haul regularly, and thatā€™s a pretty substantial expenseā€¦), this trailer did not have brakes.

4 Likes

Man I would really hope that the rental company would require brakes. Is it even legal to haul without?

3 Likes

They do make controllers that are in-line with the plug, that you connect to your phone with an app. Maybe they do that.

Itā€™s not entirely clear to me if this was a ā€œrentalā€ or if they ā€œrented itā€ from a friend or barn-mate.

4 Likes

Excellent point. I read ā€œrentalā€ and never considered anything but it coming from an actual company that rents a horse trailer. (And would presumably have some sort of requirements regarding haul vehicle!)

Borrowing from a friend is definitely a whole nother ball of wax :grimacing:

8 Likes

Does California not require a yearly safety inspection?

Lack of manual might simply be because everyone likes to have things digital and online now. Google your trailer and look for a manual.