[QUOTE=Shadow14;4188762]
Never beleived it for a minute myself but that is one arguement the barefooters are putting forward over shod horses.[/QUOTE]Can we amend this to say that some hard-core, over-the-top barefooters are saying such things?
If one is looking to taking a horse barefoot simply as a way to save money, then that isn’t a particularly good reason to pull shoes. It may be a compelling reason, but it isn’t a good one. Why? Because boots can help a horse who is pretty much dependent upon shoes to make the transition more comfortable while he grows in hoof wall that will better support his needs. And boots cost money. They are also, as rainechyldes has said, a PIA. So going barefoot simply to save money means isn’t necessarily good for the horse.
If you are pulling shoes because you want your horse to have the benefits of being bare, then that is a much better reason. Boots offer protection while riding, so if you are willing to face the initial PIA factor, then they are a viable option. I like to take off my shoes when I come into the house, and put them back on when I go outside. Temporary protection is kinda nice. Yes, I have to take time to lace my boots. Darn! Then again, I have different shoes for my different needs. Hmmm. That’s why I also have several brands of hoof boots for my guys.
Can horses go totally bare? Obviously, they can. Can every horse go totally bare and stay sound? I seriously doubt it because of the many conformational problems we see in domestic horses. But, just because a horse is initially uncomfortable when the shoes are pulled does not mean he isn’t a candidate for going totally bare. If his hoof structure has been supported by shoes for years, his feet may need time for these structures to strengthen in response to barefoot conditions. It doesn’t necessarily happen in a month. Or two. Depending on what needs to improve, it can take much longer. This takes commitment on the rider’s part, and it takes creativity to keep a horse like this comfortable. It is much, much easier to simply go back to shoes, regardless of the cost.
So no, financial reasons don’t really fly for trying barefoot. Of course, if your horse has always had great feet, he may not even notice that his shoes have been pulled. He may not be tender at all. But why would this horse have been shod in the first place? Chances are, he wouldn’t have been.