I read every one of the Black Stallion books (from the public library) until the Everglades one. That one was so over-the-top out-there, in no way consistent with the previous Black Stallion books, that I was out on it after that.
I looked up some wiki on the series and Farley. Had not realized that the first Black Stallion was published in 1941. It would have been written before the U.S. entered WWII, especially with the long publishing cycle in those days.
The entire series, as it is offered to the public, is not the consistent storyline as we know series today. Some of the books aren’t about The Black at all, even though they are included in the series. “The Horse Tamer” was a life-changing book for me.
And there are definitely some continuity issues with some of the books. But they were published years apart, so perhaps expectations were different at the time.
Farley (1915-1989) was writing the series for 42 years, from the time he was in high school, publishing the first book while he was still in college, until 7 years before his death in 1989 aged 74. Most of the early books, through the 50’s and early 60’s, were immersed in the racing industry as it was then.
During the second half of the 60’s, when Farley was in his late 40’s and older, the series began to drift seriously, to my reading. The whole series is considered “Young Adult”. Publishing was even more rigid then than it is now. I’ll hazard a guess that Farley had pressure from publishers to update his plots and themes to the rapidly changing youth culture of the time.
But I’ll further guess that an older man like Farley (49 and counting when book #17 was published in 1964), obviously deep into a racing culture that didn’t permit women in the barn area at all, and didn’t allow female jockeys until 1969 (and not much then), was maybe not the best able to keep up with it.
- Quote from jockey Bill Hartack – I’m sure he spoke for many racetrackers at the time
“They’ll find out how tough it is and they’ll give it up. The tracks won’t have to worry about being flooded with women because a female cannot compete against a male doing anything….They might weigh the same as male jockeys, but they aren’t as strong. And as a group, I don’t think their brains are as capable of making fast decisions. Women are also more likely to panic. It’s their nature.”
The 1971 book is when Alec’s love interest was actually in the barns as a groom and a rider. And so forth. It read to me like a writer who is trying to keep up with things that aren’t really in his wheelhouse. Even though I was young myself at the time.
From there, as far as I was concerned, book #18 (1969) set in the Florida Everglades with the shaman and the ghost horse is when the whole thing slid off a cliff in terms of quality. To me, that book was like reading about a bad LSD trip. Other than the character names, in no way did it track with the series to that point. As far as I was concerned.
1971 was The Black Stallion and The Girl, published when Farley was 64. It was 11 years before the next one was published, the one where Alec flees to the west with The Black (The Black being about 45 yo by then, by my calculation, unless the book was set at an earlier period in the series). One more book co-authored by Farley’s son Steven in 1983 (as a prequel), and that was the end of it.
Farley died at 74 in 1989. Overall he was in his element with the racing culture of the book through the 40’s, 50’s, and first few years of the 60’s. After that, it seems to me that the giant cultural changes of the youth throughout the late 60’s and 70’s seemed to have overwhelmed him as an older man writing YA books. But that’s just my opinion.