HI- I actually have a lot of info on this…might be able to help a little. I actually recently moved back to New York, from the Bay Area California. I was a working student at Barbier’s place in Healdsburg for a time, while I got my Equine Science degree nearby. I was there about 6 months, right before I moved here. I have some actual, first hand experience with him. I’m going back into racing, but I can tell you what I know…
1- Just FYI, Healdburg, where he is located, is about 1 1/2 hours away from San Fran proper. And that’s with no traffic. Certain days/times you could easily be looking at a 2 hour drive from the San Fran area. He is in Sonoma County, not Marin County. It took me over 45 minutes one way daily-- from Santa Rosa. Riverside Equestrian is a bit closer, and they have some good trainers.
2- I would suggest you do some lessons with Shanna, the assistant trainer. She is fantastic. She’s a phenomenal horsewoman who is tough on you, but really brings out your best. If you have any skill at all, you will excel with her. I took most of my lessons with Shanna
3- The horses… the horses are amazing. No doubt about it. The schoolmaster horses are really just amazing creatures. Orghulo was by far my favorite, and I suggest you try to get a lesson on him, if your skill level allows. If you like Lusitanos, you will leave your lessons LOVING them.
4- He is eccentric, and a character. He has a great sense of humor. But he’s not for everyone. I joked and said anyone under the age of 25 probably will not “get” him. He stays very true to Classical Dressage… and you have to ask yourself if his methods are ones that you agree with. I’m not going to tell you he’s great or not great-- it’s totally subjective.
I WILL say he is knowledgeable, humane, and safe. Those are three of the most important factors, I think…for ANY trainer you choose. The rest is just your own preferences in style, ect. You need to go to the barns, take a look around, ask questions, trust your gut.
I personally have experience with Barbier, Jack Burns, Lilo Fore and Gail McGuffey and Christine Rivlin. If you have any questions on them, you can PM me. Good luck!