I LOVE this forum!! The “bathtub method” is fabulous! I don’t know why anyone would try to break in tall boots without doing this!
At about 8:00 am yesterday I put on socks, breeches and boots. I submerged the boots in a bathtub full of warm water (for about 1 minute, took my legs out, and then submerged them again for another 45 second). I could not believe it - as soon as they were wet, they felt so much better around the calf. I went to the barn, did a few things and then rode in them (which in and of itself is a miracle, since they were so tight around the calf before I can’t imagine what it would have been like to try to ride in them), and then left the boots on ALL day. And I do mean ALL day. I finally took them off at about midnight.
My calves are a little sore from being in the boots all day, and the backs of my knees are a bit sore because they still need to fall. But when I put them on this morning, they zipped up like custom made boots - still snug, but zipped with no problem.
Thank you all for sharing your experiences with this method – I never would have had the courage to submerge brand new, expensive boots in water if you all had not told me how helpful this process is!