NY Times Article: Black Equestrians Want to Be Safe. But They Can’t Find Helmets

From a purely engineering point of view…

I agree that different natural hairstyles should be considered. But the only things I really see as a potential solution would be sizing helmets up to accommodate more volume, and looking into material development for liners that can compensate for the abrupt changes in pressure that braids and such can create. And its not just the top, the back of the skull needs to be protected too, that has to be taken into consideration.

The problem with this, potentially, could be the cost these materials could be and the effects of extra volume on safety. One of the big discussion points is being able to accommodate people interested in trying the sport that can’t fit in conventional helmets. But if the only way to make helmets to an acceptable safety standard to accommodate for the effects of something like locs, for example, is to use a specially designed material that can overcome the physical effects of impact on that texture, that could still price people out of trying the sport. Simplest solution could be to just size up helmets and use cheaper lining, but there’s the chance that could severely affect the helmet’s safety features.

Some companies definitely should step up and do the research, but people do have to realize that there might not end up being a good answer. Hopefully, with all the advances in material design, it could be figured out, but there’s the chance that there might not be a cost-effective way to accommodate some types of hair while maintaining acceptable safety standards. You can only fight physics so much, and there are always more variables to consider that might not be obvious at first glance. That doesn’t mean nothing should be done, but it’s also not as simple as “they make football helmets for different hair so why can’t they do it for equestrians”. And a company will have to be okay with potentially taking a huge loss in researching and trying to develop a solution to find out it just can’t be done safely, as well as public reaction if the results end up being “we cant do it”. While I don’t think most companies are intentionally trying to block people out of the sport, I also can’t really fault them for not being willing to take a huge financial risk in this environment.

I do think one potential path forward could be crowd funding for research (I think someone else mentioned this). I would absolutely contribute to that.

14 Likes

@TwiSedai All of those points are totally valid, and I don’t think anyone here is refuting that.

You explained the difficulties in a respectful, inclusive manner that didn’t diminish anyone, or any culture. You used the correct terms and displayed an attitude of understanding and desire for empathy. The Back On track guy didn’t. At all. He was dismissive and doubled down on it. Various posters didn’t.

Your response was the right response. Someone should send your response to him :wink:

7 Likes

Yes. Often it is the unthinking, knee-jerk response that is so offensive. Imagine being a person who hears that sort of attitude on issues that personally impact them day after day.

3 Likes

I just saw an Instagram about Champion making a custom vest for a young boy who had a Hickman line, and they created him a custom one so that he could ride without pressure on the line.

One of the comments said Champion also made helmets for a rider who had scar tissue to accommodate it.

3 Likes

So, I’ve been away from this thread for a while, came back, started scrolling, saw this, haven’t scrolled all the way down to see how/if others have responded which I’ll fully concede is my bad if I’m repeating anything that’s been said, but:

I don’t think ANYONE is alleging intentional choices on the part of helmet manufacturers to only design helmets for White equestrians or that these manufacturers are intentionally excluding Black equestrians and/or other Equestrians of color, plus people of any ethnicity/race who have voluminous, curly hair.

Rather, I think people are merely raising that this is an issue in the first place and a very real issue and something that does make our sport/hobby/lifestyle (using 3 words b/c not everyone is competitive) less accessible to ALL people who desire to participate and have the means to do so and makes it more dangerous for people who maybe still opt to ride but can’t find a helmet that fits.

I don’t have the answer to how to address this from a scientific “how to safely fit a large quantity of hair in a helmet” standpoint but it can’t be addressed at all if helmet manufacturers aren’t aware and then respond poorly or don’t respond at all if made aware.

EDIT: this isn’t just a problem with equestrian sports or with sports or with any singular activity humans participate in. Inclusivity is something that yes, can, should and needs to be considered in ALL aspects of life. It’s not strictly a race/ethnicity item either, there’s also disability inclusivity, etc.

3 Likes

Well I just said this but you said it sooner and more succinctly. :slight_smile: