I have a black forest saddle I’m selling. Didn’t work for me.
I’ve tried several synthetic saddles. The wintec western is great. I’m selling one of those as my mom has retired from riding. Those are nearly indestructible, but they only fit a certain type of horse.
English wintec saddles don’t fit my horses. A friend used them for her percheron cross and welsh pony so they fit her cobby types. I honestly don’t care for them.
Thorowgoods are much more comfortable than wintecs. The seat has so much more cushion. I didn’t care for the stirrup location on mine, but it was way too big for me. So maybe if i found one that actually fit, i would be pleased. But it does have a wide twist which I didn’t like.
Tekna saddles are the newer synthetic saddles on the market. The material is much better than either wintec or thorowgood. I cannot tell you how much i love the material. It is like a synthetic rubber- not really sure how to describe it. It grips you in without rubbing in any way. If you ride in the rain it maintains it’s grip no matter how wet you get. Pouring rain and your saddle is not slick at all. I love it!
It doesn’t have the padding that thorowgood does. Now if they added some different size trees for different horses, and padded the seat, they would be in higher demand.
But it does have a super narrow twist and a small seat. Ordering a bigger seat size will not help you there either. Bigger riders will not be comfortable because it will be tight in front of you. Trying to find a polite way of saying that. The other problem is that you are limited on what horses it fits- they don’t have the fit options that thorowgood has. It does have a changeable gullet.
I have only tried the dressage seat, not the close contact. Can’t comment on the close contact.
Tekna came out with a new western/Aussie hybrid saddle with an exchangeable gullet. It’s only available in Australia but the price is affordable. I’m debating on buying one. Like I said, i absolutely love the material. The idea of a western one is very appealing. But I’m afraid I will order it and find out it doesn’t fit. If it works, it would be the first western type saddle with an exchangeable gullet on the market. I wish I could get one on trial.