Rhino at MD tracks?

Originally posted by LGW:
I really want to go over each response to this thread before I write my “opinion”. What I do see is a lot of mention regarding the state vet. Perhaps, it would do a lot of us good instead of fighting to understanding what the Maryland State Vet- had as his opinion of doing what was best?

With saying that, last year the MD Governor tried very hard to make betting on horse racing legal within his state. Initially, I was in support of that. Now seeing how the recent virus outbreak was dealt with, I withdraw my support.

What in the hell does that mean? Are youi trying to tell me that all those people at Laurel and Pimlico every single day of the week are betting illegally on horses? And now that the state vet didn’t close Pimlico down when the outbreak started, you don’t want betting on horse racing to be legal? WTF???

I am a relative newcomber to the horse world and have unfortunately been the victim of what I would consider some very poor decision making by “those in charge.” I am the owner of the horse that was euthanized in Kent County, MD early Sunday morning. Below, I have attached the tribute to my beautiful mare, Pet.

The purpose in my posting on this forum is to obtain some feedback from those in the racing business as to how we,“the collective” horse world can do a better job in the control of this horrendous disease. As in the cases at Pimlico, poor management and control of this disease affects everyone. Short-sided decisions have had tremendous consequences for all involved.

I agree that closing facilities may not be the answer. Lack of contact (close or otherwise) is the only full proof prevention for this disease. So, as in the situation of Pimlico, why could there not be some form of notice provided to owners, trainers, … and, I don’t mean a post on the State Ag website. I mean notice given to everyone on the premises that the disease is present there. Notice would give the owners/trainers the opportunity to take their own risk by keeping or shipping a horse into that facility. In our case, I don’t believe that the owner of the filly would have sent her to Pim and certainly the farm would not have accepted her.

Time is of essence in the communication of information about this disease. In the case of my horse, she had a fever 4 days, 1 day neuro and that was it. A dead horse is not the point at which we should be communicating. From what I read here, temps are taken on many of the horses that are being trained. Temps are the first indication of the disease.

I have posted similar messages on the Eventing website and would appreciate thoughts and feedback. Eliminating and containing this disease (which KILLS and disables horses) is in all of our best interest. (if you’re interested in reading about this lovely mare,please do…if not, just skip) But, I would really appreciate some thoughts here. Thanks

Pet

1999-2006

Her name was Test Pattern, she was a 16.2, chestnut thoroughbred mare, seven-years old this spring, a top-preliminary eventing champion. Kim (her breeder and trainer) told me that they started with “Pat” but it didn’t fit, so Pet was the name that evolved for this beautiful animal, who was more dog than horse.

I have pretty much started everything in life a little late. I always loved horses and my family actually won a horse at a soccer game in Kansas City, who turned out to be in foal, so actually I guess I won two horses, Craemer and Gidget whose fates are still unknown to me, as we were not financially equipped to keep those horses. We ended up at Kim’s farm by chance, when our daughter needed to move her long-outgrown pony from another barn. I would wander around the farm and look at these beautiful animals, Pet was the special one. I met her when she was three, I was forty-three (I really meant late in life). I hadn’t ridden a horse since Gidget, when I was 9. which at that point consisted of a bareback mount around the back-yard.

I took lessons at the barn on another horse for about 9 months and then the owners asked if I wanted to buy Pet. Again in the position of not being able to afford either the purchase or the board, my dear husband gave a nod and the newest member of our family was added. I never sat on Pet before we bought her. I was terrified and excited all at the same time. Terrified perhaps by the knowledge of the dangers of the sport and the too much realization of my age, I preceded at a walk and then a trot on this fairly newly broken young mare. Kim used to refer to us as “learning together.” I was blessed with a trainer who was long on patience with me and terrifically talented and dedicated to her horses.

Our first months were a little bumpy, Pet clipped a rail injured her leg and we walked and walked and walked until she got better. By the end of winter in 2004, Pet was ready to do some competing. And so, Kim and Pet launched into the event world that spring, owner in tow, most of time soaking up anything and everything about what they were doing (I had no clue). I guess that it was early April that year that my husband and I also found out that we were pregnant with twins ( I really meant that I started everything a little late). So far as the horse went though, we never missed a beat, Kim and I decided I would help her train Pet (she was always very generous on my side of the contribution here, I groomed and she trained.) and she would continue to compete her.

There were more than a few people who gasped when I told them I was having twins, even more when I told them that I rode Pet (a five year old then) until I was about five-months pregnant. Granted, we were not galloping in some open field, we were just doing our walk-trot thing around the indoor ring. When I couldn’t’ ride anymore, I spent all my ride-time, helping Kim with Pet. I watched the majority of her training, I groomed and washed her everyday and I intently watched as she and Kim had a great time together out there doing their thing. It was an experience I will always cherish.

The last competition that year was in late October. My husband and I drove three uncomfortable hours to the event (I was eight months pregnant) to watch Kim and Pet take home 2nd place. Frank has always supported my enthusiasm with Pet, even when it meant he had to drive me, the time together offered an opportunity to talk (we also have a 10 and 13 year old) about whatever was happening in our lives, but mostly we just gushed about Kim and Pet.

In November, 2004 Jack and Nellie arrived (and yes, they are the most beautiful babies). Life changed for me in a lot of ways, with a part of that figuring out how to find the time to ride Pet and get back to the barn. I can’t say I jumped right back in. I think it was late January before I actually sat on Pet again. And, true to form, we started to do that walk-trot (and now canter and a few jumps ) thing. Pet was an amazing animal, she could go out and do these amazing athletic events and then stand by the truck as if she were out in the field grazing.

My sister, who is deathly afraid of horses, brought her three kids out to visit (all teenagers). Of course, I had to take them to the barn. I was so proud of Pet, she was so special. All the kids jumped on to “take a ride” around the indoor ring. I will never forget my 16 year-ld nephew doing the giddy-up thing and Pet just walking lazily along. By the end of the six kids taking a ride on Pet, my sister, after witnessing the gentleness of this creature, set her camera down and took a ride on Pet. Pet will never understand the incredible gap that she closed from sheer terror to “that wasn’t half bad.”

Pet was just a wonderful horse. She was the alpha-mare bitch in the field, she was a tough and talented competitor and she was my friend.

Almost 10 days ago, we lost her Pet’s full sister Ting (Just Testing) to the neurological form of Equine Herpes Virus (EHV-1). How this virus traveled to our barn is a horrific act of negligence by “some” in the racing industry but certainly not the focus of this memorial. Approximately 3-days prior to Ting’s death, Kim was notified that one of the horses who had been shipped to the farm, had co-existed in a barn that had a confirmed death from the neurological form of EHV-1 at the race track. Even though Kim took precautionary steps to segregate this horse upon its arrival to the farm, the notification came too late. The barn had contracted this deadly disease.

After a significant amount of research and fueled by a pit in my stomach that kept me up at night, I discovered that in actuality, there had been three horses put down at this track, all confirmed with EHV-1 and all in different barns. Now with Ting’s death, another horse going “neuro” and other fevers at the farm, Kim was catapulted from national event-rider/competitor, trainer and horse owner into a one-person 24-hour horse nursing care provider for all of these precious animals. Kim took temperatures on eighteen horses two to three times a day. Each day some progress, each day some set backs, as another horse begins showing neurological symptoms and another treated horse begins to recover.

Pet showed an elevated temperature one day, that was normal the next… She bounced a couple of times but the pit in my stomach stayed firmly in place. I felt helpless beyond words to support Kim during this crisis and would run supplies, paint and food to her so that she could stay focused on the animals. When I walked into the indoor ring that morning to see Pet, I knew. She was different. I don’t know how to describe it in technical words or maybe even in horse language, but it looked like every muscle in her back had just let go. She was standing, moving, albeit dragging her feet, and if you didn’t know her you would just think that she didn’t feel good. I think that what I saw was in her eyes. Obviously, horses can’t talk, and it is weird because my babies don’t talk either, but I can tell the cry of pain, or “I just lost my binky, or even “Jack just took my toy.” Maybe it is being a new mom, maybe it is a tuition thing, maybe it was just the pit in my stomach, but I knew something was really wrong. I called the vet and I spoke with Kim and everyone assured me that horses recover from this and that she was not as bad as Terra or Meryl.

The next morning when I got to the barn the DiDi (our vet) was there with Kim in the ring. They had already catheterized Pet, as her bladder was paralyzed. She was up, but staggering, unsteady and continually moving right to catch her balance. You could tell that she just wanted to lean against something. Didi asked me to call the hospital to get another catheter so we could put it in her. In the time that I went to make the call in the house, Pet went down. Before I left for the hospital, I ran to see Pet, she was on her right side and Kim, Kelly and Didi were rubbing her legs and stroking her neck. That damn pit in my stomach. I drove madly to the hospital, where the very concerned hospital administrator laid out for me 4 different catheters. I picked the largest and the smallest hoping they would be the right ones.

After the half hour drive to and from the hospital, I arrived back at the farm, where the very
concerned State Vet personnel were talking with Kim and Didi. They did not go see Pet, they did understand our concern and left some “biosecurity booties” and literature on the disease. Upon entering the ring, Pet was still on her right side and Didi was in process of inserting the catheter to which Pet objected thoroughly (which was a good sign). We then tried to get her up.

I’ve never witnessed a horse that can’t rise. I don’t ever want to watch it again. After her third or forth attempt, I had to go outside. I couldn’t watch anymore. It was pouring rain, I paced frantically, it was beyond description. I went back to the ring and they were going to try again. Pet was pissed. We were trying to get her on her left side, no way, she rolled she put her feet out and everyone rapidly pulled the ropes off her so she wouldn’t get tangled. She stood.

Pet wandered around the indoor without stopping for about 15 minutes. I had my husband run and get her treats, from the other barn… I grabbed small bits of hay to feed her. I walked with her the entire time. I feed her all her treats and continued her hay. We set up the barrels to put the hay on and her water. She wandered to the other side of the ring and started to stagger. She was desperately trying to catch herself. She crashed into the barrels, her hind legs unable to hold her anymore and she was down.

We all stopped, took a break. Didi left. We all went into the house and ate. It was a waiting game. She needed to rest. I went to the barn before I went home to relieve our babysitter and told her how proud I was of her. She was a fighter and she would get better.

On my way home, I called my sister in Kansas. I sobbed. I just could not help her. I was so afraid and this damn knot in my stomach. I talked to the vet again, she was now at home. I told her to tell me what was the worst thing that could happen. I wanted to know. I needed to be prepared. i got home and fed the babies. Nellie could not sleep. She cried and cried. I cried and cried. My husband called a few hours later, no change. Pet was on her side, they were rolling her every couple of hours. He called again to say he was coming home. Five minutes later Kim called. She’s worse.

On the way to the barn my knot went away, I knew. I got in the indoor ring. Kim and Kelly were laying with Pet. Kim at her head, Kelly on her body. Pet was spasming every 10 seconds or so. I took my place at her neck and told her it was ok. She needed to let go, it was ok. The half an hour that it took the vet to get there was a life altering experience. Pet seemed to have less intense spasms, it was more involuntary than anything.

Didi arrived she looked at Pet, checked her eyes, her heart, touched her legs and looked directly at me and said “ I can sedate her which will prolong her life, but I can not guaranty that she will be any different when she wakes up.” I told her that I did not know my options. I wanted her to tell me what to do. She looked at me directly and said “you should put her down.” I shook my head, I could not talk. Didi went to the truck. I walked around to Pet’s head. I said goodbye. We all told her how much we loved her, how special she was and how blessed we were to have her as a part of our lives.

Today, Pet is up there jumping big fences, grazing green fields and being the alpha-bitch of heaven. I am down here, today, broken-hearted but thanking God for gracing my life and giving me the opportunity and privilege of knowing this wonderful and beautiful animal, Pet.

I really want to go over each response to this thread before I write my “opinion”. What I do see is a lot of mention regarding the state vet. Perhaps, it would do a lot of us good instead of fighting to understanding what the Maryland State Vet- had as his opinion of doing what was best?

With saying that, last year the MD Governor tried very hard to make betting on horse racing legal within his state. Initially, I was in support of that. Now seeing how the recent virus outbreak was dealt with, I withdraw my support.

Originally posted by SeaOat:
Ack, the horse from barn A was put down today.

Barn A at which track?

Not to speak for SeaOat as she can obviously do that for herself. My take on her question was did they cancel all the shows/events in the state when their was a breakout at the columboa horse center. The obvious answer to that is no.

If I had been in charge I would have shut Pimlico’s gates day one and let racing continue at Laurel for Bowie and Laurel horses. That is what they did at Penn National and as a result only one horse became ill, and none died.
Keep in mind that I am at Pimlico, so I am hurting my own pocketbook when I say that, but in my opinion it would have been the correct way to handle it.
The Kent County farm wouldn’t have been an issue in the above scenario.

According to the article below there is no case of Rhino at Fair HIll but they did close off the training center in order to prevent any contagious horses coming in.

from the thouroughbred times .com

Posted: 2/11/2006 3:19:00 PM

Fair Hill Training Center temporarily closes to avoid EHV-1

In a move to avoid equine herpesvirus (EHV-1), which has affected horses at the Maryland tracks of Pimlico Race Course and Laurel Park, Fair Hill Training Center has closed for three weeks and has hired state troopers to monitor the gates around the clock to make sure no horses enter or leave the grounds.

Fair Hill President Kathleen Anderson, who is also a veterinarian, said no horse among the 400 stabled at the facility has been confirmed with the disease. The closure was ordered by the Fair Hill board of directors on February 3 after discussing the issue with owners and trainers, the Wilmington News Journal reports.

Trainers stabled at Fair Hill include Graham Motion, Mike McCarthy, Michael Matz, and Steve Klesaris.

“We don’t want to call it a quarantine because we don’t have a problem,” Anderson said. “We had 100% approval from the barn owners and about 95 (percent) from the trainers to close the facility. There were people who were not happy about it, but the result is they don’t have a real vested interest like many others do. We feel that we did the right thing.”

There have also been no EHV-1 outbreaks at Bowie Training Center, where approximately 600 horses are stabled.

It just gets seemingly worse

Washington Post 2/2/06 - “Herpesvirus Scare Hits Bowie Barn”

If positive, the horse would be the first infected at Bowie, a former racetrack now used exclusively for training, since the outbreak of the virus was diagnosed Jan. 5 in a horse stabled at Pimlico Race Course in Baltimore.

Originally posted by SeaOat:
I do NOT think anyone in their right mind should have moved a horse off the grounds onto a farm though many panicy owners did. The horses in Kent Co. were just unfortunate ones to get exposed. Many owners called asking what they should do trying to get a personal approval to move their horse(s). While told it was not reccomended (or likely to be received anywhere) oodles decided to ship out anyway. Hmmm, now there’s morality for you.
And THAT is why I think there should have been a rule in place to prevent horses from leaving. To keep people from making either poorly informed or selfish decisions that have consequences for others. --Jess

Edited to ad: When show horse facilities are experiencing outbreaks, do they stop all showing/hunting/endurance events or simply try to confine the known effected areas?

Yes. Case in point, last year at Columbia Horse Center. Hats off to those who worked last year’s tradegy at CHC.

As a horse owner in Maryland and one who watches the news twice a day and reads three newspapers (all of which would consider this virus as newsworthy) I was not aware of an outbreak until weeks after the first death.

Seems to me, the race tracks didn’t inform the public as did Columbia Horse Center and the agriculture department was quick to shut down CHC, but not the tracks?

BloodHorse 1/26/06 - “Another Horse Euthanized at Pimlico; Laurel Park Cancels Two Racing Cards”

Another horse has been euthanized at Laurel Park after testing positive for equine herpesvirus (EHV-1). A private veterinarian of trainer Joe Delozier euthanized General Strike Jan. 25. The 3-year-old showed no signs of improvement after testing positive for the virus Jan. 19.

Since Jan. 1, 11 horses have tested positive for the virus causing the Maryland Jockey Club to place Pimlico Race Course under quarantine Jan. 21. Three horses have been euthanized, while eight horses from Barns 5 and 6 are currently in isolation in the Detention Barn.

In connection to the virus, officials at the MJC have decided not to card live racing Jan. 29 and Feb. 5. Laurel will continue to race four days a week, on a Wednesday through Saturday schedule.

A shortage of entries, stemming from a quarantine of 500 horses at Pimlico and restrictions on the movement of Thoroughbreds in and out of the state due to EHV-1, led to the scheduling to decision by chief operating officer Lou Raffetto after discussions with Maryland Thoroughbred Horsemen’s Association president Richard Hoffberger.

“We are working with a limited pool of horses and it has taken its toll on our entries,” Raffetto said. “Cutting back to four days a week the next two weeks will allow us to have the quality and quantity we were accustomed to before the outbreak of the virus.”

Since the restrictions began Jan. 6, the average field size has been 7.3 per race. In 21 live days in December, Laurel averaged 8.6 starters per race.

Races from Jan. 29 will be used as extras for Feb. 1. The races in the condition book for Feb. 5 will be used as extras for Feb. 3-4.

Equine herpesvirus causes upper respiratory infections in horses and is also known to cause neurological disease. There is currently no known method to reliably prevent the neurologic form of EHV-1. It is recommended to maintain appropriate vaccination procedures in an attempt to reduce the incidence of the respirator for of EHV-1, which may help prevent the neurologic form.

As luck would have it - or not - we sent a string of horses to Maryland for the winter. They’re stabled and trained at Bowie, but now I’m spooked about going to Laurel to run. The races aren’t filling and, while it’s a great opportunity to run in small fields, at what risk? My one and only horse is there too.

This winter has really turned out to be a bust! Sal had intended to run at Penn, Charlestown, Philly and Laurel and now, of course, he’s quarantined. I just want the powers that be to do whatever they have to do to get this under control…fast!

Originally posted by SeaOat:
Horse & ponies at Bowie cleared as are barns 5 & 8 at Pimlico. Hoping rest are soon to follow.
For the most part, MD was able to keep racing up and control the outbreak fairly well, w/ only a few bloops (lessons learned).
Hats off…

If you check over on the Eventing board, you’ll see that they’ve pretty much destroyed the life of a local event trainer. She unknowingly took in an exposed horse from a friend. (with friend’s like that, who needs enemies!) Her 15 year old daughter cradled her horse’s head in her lap while put down. Her own international prospect, if he survives, is ruined. Another horse she bred and raised also had to be put down. As one horse starts to improve, another spikes a fever.

Of course, MD had no problem shutting down her barn within ONE HOUR of notice. Not that they needed to. She’s completely out of business while she spends 24 hours/day trying to save the 19 horses in her care that were exposed thanks to Maryland putting race profits over control.

You may call that a bloop. I call it criminal.

I remember when EIA was a scourge. My father’s first and last excursion into racing ended when he horse he bought turned out to be a carrier. We eradicated that disease through very strict controls. Maybe that’s something to consider for the neurologic version of herpes.

JaGold:

Nonetheless, quit swearing at me

You question my moral integrity (now edited) and you have the nerve to ask me to stop swearing at you? Piss off.

I mentioned “pricey” because you spoke of the “international prospect” in your own previous post, so get off your high horse if I can’t make a point about my little horse.

You asked other questions I’ve already answered. Regardless, I’ve nothing else to say to you.

…not been informed of anyone positive at FH (not suggesting there isn’t, just that we’re usually up to snuff on those things), only knew they closed up to all incoming/outgoing traffic early on.
Edited to add: Well, no one told MD but apparently FH does have a positive & a barn is quarantined. Nice to learn it through the media!

“And THAT is why I think there should have been a rule in place to prevent horses from leaving. To keep people from making either poorly informed or selfish decisions that have consequences for others. --Jess”

Is that what they do with the show/event/hunt/endurance horses? Everyone stops moving/competing that has been exposed? Nope…and you don’t see them begging the State Vet to stop movement. Impossible and not scientifically feasable!

Originally posted by SeaOat:
I mentioned “pricey” because you spoke of the “international prospect” in your own previous post, so get off your high horse if I can’t make a point about my little horse.

No, I didn’t. That was mairzedoats’s post. --Jess

Originally posted by Laurierace:
If I had been in charge I would have shut Pimlico’s gates day one and let racing continue at Laurel for Bowie and Laurel horses. That is what they did at Penn National and as a result only one horse became ill, and none died.
I wholeheartedly agree that THIS would have been the responsible course of action. I don’t think and didn’t suggest that racing should have been shut down. I think that shipments out of Plimco should have been shut down. The track should have been held to as high standards as the private barn that was affected. And as you said, this would have prevented the spread of infection.

SeaOat, you characterized the mistakes made in the handling of this outbreak as “a few bloops.” I pointed out that the CONSEQUENCES of these “bloops” were that horses died. That elevates the mistakes above “bloops” in my book. When the consequences are needlessly high, I don’t think those responsible for them deserve kuddos. --Jess

Right now Penn, Philly, all MD tracks and Ct are on restrictions for outside horses. Here at MNR they are not letting in horses from PA, MD and KY. The restriction for CT went into effect at 1pm on sunday. MNR is thinking about clsoing to all outside horses. Meaning only horses stabled at MNR will be allowed to race. The commission was supposed to be having a meeting today about it.

I have the official letter from the State of DE vet downstairs, but he is now requiring vaccination certificates for all horses traveling in DE (show to show, race to race, or just overall I’m not sure without the letter) and vaccinations given by veterinarians or @ least purchased from veterinarians. I work tomorrow, but will try to remember to grab the letter and post it word for word for you guys …

Charles Town is closed to any and every outside horse. As of Saturday there was no cases at CT