Creepiest: When I boarded at a large barn in a very populated area there were no trails to speak of, so I decided one evening to explore the hilly, wooded, undeveloped lot near the barn. As it was getting dark I stumbled on what looked like a path and started following it up a hill. As we went, my mare started getting antsy and suddenly spun and tried to gallop back to the barn. I got her back under control and tried to head back up the hill, but she Would. Not. Go. Well, even though I now had a creepy feeling, I couldn’t let her get away with that! So, despite her thudding heart, wild eyes, jigging and snorting, I finally got her to the top of the rise where I had just enough time to take in stones and animal skulls surrounding a large dark red pentacle drawn on the ground before my mare reared straight up and ran for home.
A week or so later there was a story in the paper about a pentacle and the carcasses of sacrificed small animals found on a beach less than a mile from those woods.