Since the thread is still relevant…
I have both Sorels and Mucks, and the Sorels are much heavier. I definitely prefer the Mucks. Wouldn’t be without them.
I was wondering why nobody mentioned Noble Outfitter boots. I had Muck boots and Mudster and dislike them both. Somehow my feet sweat in them despite being cold and ended up freezing in cold weather. The Noble Outfitter boots have kept my feet warm and dry.
Check out the black boots with grey cuffs at London Trading Post (Canada). They weigh nothing and are the warmest boots I’ve ever had including Sorels, Muck boots and Bogs. I do put ice grippers on when slippery but these boots are fabulous and inexpensive - $59.00 Can. I didn’t say they were beautiful! Also so easy to kick on and off. I do wish they were just a bit higher. Made in Poland. They are wonderful.
