time to put an end to top hats in dressage

British dressage rider Fiona Bigwood suffered a serious TBI in a fall from her GP horse at a competition. The fall was not in competition, and she was wearing a helmet, which split in two.

British grand prix rider in hospital with severe concussion after fall

The Chronicle ran this, which shows a number of Rolex riders in non-protective headgear. I’m at the point where I think it would be a responsible policy for an equestrian publication to not publish photos of riders in top hats. You want to see your photo in the media, then wear a helmet.

There is no sane reason at all to allow soft-sided headwear when riding in competition under NGB or IGB rules.

I’m much more direct. It is time the FEI got off their a$$ and required helmets. Period.

Frankly, I have zero respect for any rider clinging to a top hat, at this stage. They just look egotistical and stupid.

Oh dear, does a$$ equate to cursing and will I be in trouble on the other thread for that and not having seen Midnight Cowboy? :wink:

I agree - I was sad to see some riders revert to top hats who have worn helmets recently. Why do they go back?

I too was disappointed and surprised to see the top hats. :sigh:

Agreed.

Tonight my mail included the catalog for the official USEF supplements…containing photos of riders without helmets.

I just don’t get it.

That’s pretty bad.

[QUOTE=jenm;7554054]
That’s pretty bad.[/QUOTE]

The brochure has more without helmets than the three of these ladies, but I’m too lazy to photograph and post the brochure.

http://thisismyhorse.platinumperformance.com/2013/02/jamie-pestana/
http://thisismyhorse.platinumperformance.com/2013/02/mette-rosencrantz/
http://thisismyhorse.platinumperformance.com/2013/02/charlotte-bredahl-baker/

All of these riders are very well respected, and I mean no ill will by linking the site - they were breaking no rules by showing in top hats. I’m only linking the dressage riders because that was the topic of this thread. None of the Western discipline riders was wearing a helmet.

[QUOTE=right horse at the right time;7554079]
The brochure has more without helmets than the three of these ladies, but I’m too lazy to photograph and post the brochure.

http://thisismyhorse.platinumperformance.com/2013/02/jamie-pestana/
http://thisismyhorse.platinumperformance.com/2013/02/mette-rosencrantz/
http://thisismyhorse.platinumperformance.com/2013/02/charlotte-bredahl-baker/

All of these riders are very well respected, and I mean no ill will by linking the site - they were breaking no rules by showing in top hats. I’m only linking the dressage riders because that was the topic of this thread. None of the Western discipline riders was wearing a helmet.[/QUOTE]

What boggles my mind is that any Young Riders (Jamie Pestana is the example in this) would ride without a helmet. Maybe it’s just me, but I’m not far from Jamie’s age (within a year or two) and I have never ridden a horse without a helmet. It’s just never even occurred to me. I put a helmet on even if I’m just going to sit on the horse for a second for a picture or something.

I have a better understanding of the reasons why people who have grown up without helmets don’t wear them, for showing or otherwise - but WHY would a Young Rider show without one?! It’s very hard for me to understand.

What I do not understand is how the USEF does not require hard hats across the board for all disciplines. There are very young children riding saddleseat, for example, without helmets. I recently judged the dressage portion of a breed show for which helmets were required for all riders where right next to our warmup were children without. Either it is a safety issue or it is not. Can’t have it both ways.

Amen, sister.

Not to mention they look straight-up ridiculous. I mean, are you performing card tricks at a kid’s birthday party, or are you an athlete?

I agree that helmets should be mandatory, across the board for all disciplines, when showing. If you want to be unsafe at home on your own time, go for it, but @ shows IMO it should be all helmets all the time. Saddleseat, reining, dressage, the whole lot of 'em.

Totally agree! Especially makes me sad to see kids riding without a helmet. My kid will never be allowed to ride without a helmet, period. It won’t even be an issue because I always wear one and so will she. It’s essential!

[QUOTE=Frizzle;7554106]
Not to mention they look straight-up ridiculous. I mean, are you performing card tricks at a kid’s birthday party, or are you an athlete?[/QUOTE]

Exactly. And I’d extend that to those penguin coats as well. The point of those is what? An expensive tradition? Why?

Dressage is supposed to be about the horse. The rider should be dressed in appropriate clothing for the task required, and the rider shouldn’t distract from the focus on the horse’s movement.

I’m thinking of hosting a bonfire for top hats and shadbellies. Think of it as the 21st century equestrian version of a 1970s bra burning. For entertainment, there’ll be a concurrent screening of Midnight Cowboy, for those whose lives are still incomplete without having seen it.

:slight_smile:

[QUOTE=JER;7554426]
Exactly. And I’d extend that to those penguin coats as well. The point of those is what? An expensive tradition? Why?

Dressage is supposed to be about the horse. The rider should be dressed in appropriate clothing for the task required, and the rider shouldn’t distract from the focus on the horse’s movement.

I’m thinking of hosting a bonfire for top hats and shadbellies. Think of it as the 21st century equestrian version of a 1970s bra burning. For entertainment, there’ll be a concurrent screening of Midnight Cowboy, for those whose lives are still incomplete without having seen it.

:)[/QUOTE]

I agree with you on that bonfire, and if you can chuck the show jumping hunt coat on there as well, you will be my hero forever and ever. :yes:

How different this conversation is (so far) from that a few years ago when the tradition (I guess it was) of top hats was considered nearly sacrosanct. Even though riders were allowed to wear helmets, almost none did.

So this thread will probably now devolve away from helmets … but really, helmets are a good topic. The more broadly helmets can continue to spread throughout all disciplines, the better.

More and more western speed-event riders, and games riders, are wearing helmets instead of the western hat. I think a helmet is becoming a sort of badge of honor that they are Serious Competitors, riding so hard they might even come off the horse in a fall hard enough to get a head injury! That is a great way to socialize helmets into that world. :wink:

Every year there are heartbreaking stories in the western riding world of children dying from falls, usually younger elementary age. I’ve seen several stories of a child riding quietly across a parking lot when a spook or something occurred, and the child came off in a fatal fall onto the pavement.

Given the child’s smaller size, there is more distance and time to the ground for them to rotate during the fall and have the head strike harder, than larger adults who tend to land on their sides or shoulders. It is inconceivable to me that a parent has some silly reason - usually appearance-based - why they don’t require their children to wear a helmet on every ride.

I know many professionals even in the “english” world have a deep well of excuses for not wearing helmets every time they ride. I think one of the real reasons is because some ride so many horses every day, they would be wearing it most of the day. Helmets have come so far in the fit and comfort department in the last few years, hopefully that progress will continue to banish those excuses. The pros with a lot of amateurs and juniors in the barn are role models, whether they wish to be or not. If they are seen schooling a horse on the flat with no helmet - in that group, it becomes ok to school a horse on the flat with no helmet, no matter how many times the pro may say ‘do as I say, not as I do’.

I still say unless it is a junior young rider, it is the individuals personal choice.
I am tired of people telling others how they should live.
I wear a helmet, but if an adult chooses not to that is their business.
Sorry just how I feel.

I think it’s remarkable that people like barrel racers who are fighting for every thousandths of a second on their time would but a big sail on their head.

I am glad Fiona was wearing a helmet, and I wish her a speedy recovery. It’s amazing how quickly a day can go from an ordinary day to a Very Bad Day.

[QUOTE=Sannois;7554467]
I still say unless it is a junior young rider, it is the individuals personal choice.
I am tired of people telling others how they should live.
I wear a helmet, but if an adult chooses not to that is their business.
Sorry just how I feel.[/QUOTE]

While I can agree with your sentiment, having seen the actual physical damage to a body in the hospital on a regular basis, wearing a helmet is the easiest and cheapest way to avoid a completely life changing experience for the entire family as well as affecting numerous others who will have to care and treat the patient. Thus, I am an advocate for requiring helmets. For those who don’t, I suggest they promise not to seek medical attention.

I must second Reed’s statement here. I do a fair amount of research in the Emergency and Trauma departments. It isn’t just the person. It is everyone around them and beyond that, many people who ride don’t have the resources to fully pay for the sequelae and we are all asked to support them on a regular basis as well as the hit to everyone’s insurance premiums, etc. I find the argument weirdly reminiscent of seatbelts, but (except for NH which only enforces for children), we now have either primary or secondary enforcement of seatbelt laws in all 50 states and DC.

I have to hugely applaud the USEF for making the rule of helmet with properly adjusted and fastened chin strap applicable to any time you are mounted, included hacking from barn, during awards ceremonies, etc.

[QUOTE=Sannois;7554467]
I still say unless it is a junior young rider, it is the individuals personal choice.
I am tired of people telling others how they should live.
I wear a helmet, but if an adult chooses not to that is their business.
Sorry just how I feel.[/QUOTE]

We are talking about “in competition” where you are already subject to and governed by rules. Others are ALREADY telling you how “to live” within the confines of the show. You can’t suddenly decide your horse needs ten laps around the outside of the dressage arena after the bell rings, or “I want to jump all the warm-up fences backwards”.

What someone does at home is their own decision (you can’t fix or regulate stupid sometimes) but, when at a show, you’re already being told what you can and can not wear. I’d prefer not to wear tight white pants, but I don’t have a choice (and, no, tan is not any better). We are just talking about a small update to existing rules.

These people are role models. Want to wear a hat at home? Go ahead - you are an idiot but more power to you. When showing at an International competition where young riders everywhere want to be you - you need to do the right thing, swallow your pride and be a good role model.