I’ve thawed them with everything from a small hand torch to sticking a crap-ton of therma-care heat pads and covering with insulation over the pads, LOL!
My husband screwed by frost-free up this winter. He thought it looked “dirty” so he dumped a bucket of water on it at night and the water trickled into it, froze and caused some damage. So now it freezes regularly. sigh (poor man certainly got yelled at for that)
Heat tape wrapped all the way up from ground to pump and then insulation tape over that. It’s kept it thawed and working all this winter, despite it being colder-than-hell all winter this year. It’s single digits or below zero more than above it, it seems.
In spring when we can dig without using dynamite, I’ll replace the hydrant. Before now though, never had a single problem with that hydrant. Apparently you can’t slowly pour 5 gallons of cold water over the top of it, “rinsing it”, when the temp is -5. Go figure…
Try the heat tape, it’s easy to find in hardware or plumbing stores. The heat gun should work, too. Heat tape will keep it working, but a heat gun will thaw it for now. Often after they freeze hard, they have issues with dripping and freezing over again though, so keep an eye on it. The heat gun will blast heat onto it despite the ambient air temp…a blow dryer can only warm the air it sucks in so many degrees. Which feels hot in a house, but if the air temp is 10 degrees then the blow dryer won’t warm it enough to thaw the hydrant.