[QUOTE=SwampYankee;6319466]
Ha-ha; :lol:! Those “purists” don’t even know they’re comparing apples with oranges! Take a look at the REAL “Classical” dressage riding, in old prints and paintings from the time of La Guerinere. They’ve got an awful lot more in common with a California style “bridle horse” than with anything seen in modern-day dressage arenas!
The truth is that modern, competitive-style dressage is only about 150 years old, and evolved around the Germanic-bred cavalry mounts of the late 19th century. Because these horses also had to go X-C, the emphasis became more and more about extension, which became a “big-mover” contest that increasingly, and regrettably, is often decided in the breeding shed.
If you look up French Classical dressage, however, you’ll find a way of riding & training not incompatible with Western riding at all; it’s Old Home Week, self-carriage in collection.
Search “Nuno Oliveira,” “Cadre Noir,” “Saumur,” “Jean-Claude Racinet” and “General Decarpentry.”
No more “Pushme-Pullyu!” ;)[/QUOTE]
YUP!
But to be honest I highly doubt we will see any REAL “bridle horse” type riding in WD. I’m yet to see a video or photo of a Western Dressage ride straight up in the bridle, reins in the wind. Modern western riding (save for the very few California Reinsmens/Vaqueros left) has gone same way everything else has gone. Poorly broke horses, push-me pull-ya, draw reins, crank n spank, over bitted, under balanced ect ect. It you find it every where, english, western, dressage ect. The Dressage world could learn a TON from the Bridle Horse crowd, but good luck convincing the dressage crowd that they have anything to learn from TRUE western riding.