I wear a Charles Owen showjumper. I sacrificed tradition for safety.
One of my pet peeves is field members who wear unapproved hunt caps. They’re not safe, and they’re not “correct” on field members. Hunt caps are for staff. Field members are supposed to wear bowlers or top hats. Most hunts have relaxed that restriction and allow approved helmets (preferably black velvet) for safety.
If you want to make a choice between safety and tradition, choose one or the other. But a field member wearing a hunt cap is being neither safe nor traditional. Some people prefer hunt caps because they think they’re more attractive than helmets. That may be true, but if you’re not staff, you’re not entitled to wear one. That’s just like wearing a scarlet coat when you haven’t been awarded that privilege, just because you think it looks better.
If you’re staff, ignore the above rant.