Another advocate of the ‘little-big guys’.
Five years ago, when I first started my struggles with dressage, I owned a 16.1 hand TB/Percheron (1/4) gelding - with the temperament of a blessed saint. But, holy goodness - I SO struggled with ‘on-the-bit’ with him. He was a tank - for someone my size - short-legged 5’1". It was so frustrating.
Then we got a 14.2 hand Nokota gelding for my daughter. In almost every single respect - the Nokota’s size and movement was SOOOO much easier for me.
I ended up selling my blessed saint of big horse, and bought a 14.2 hand Andalusian gelding. And, in fact, because my big horse was well… a big horse… I sold him for more than I paid for my purebred but small Andalusian.
I later bought a 15 hand blue roan Nokota gelding. In some respects, he’s an even better fit for me - because he’s more narrow. We fit perfectly.
Anyway, I can’t imagine going back to the over 16 hand variety. I am middle-aged adult rider and I’m just more confident in every way on my smaller (though often more fiery) horses. And, fwiw, in regards to competitiveness, both Andalusian and Nokota have placed a few times over warmbloods at modest little schooling dressage shows I occasionally dabble in!
Pictures…
My 14.2 hand Andalusian - nothing ‘small’ about him!
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/TeamNokota/HHchotrotwarmup.jpg
My 15 hand blue roan Nokota gelding
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/TeamNokota/Kentucky%20Horse%20Park%202006/KHPteaser002.jpg
Me on my daughter’s 14.2 hand Nokota gelding…
http://i4.photobucket.com/albums/y132/TeamNokota/maochico.jpg