Why so few people wearing protective vests in the jumpers?

As someone who jumps pretty much only on the hunt field, I didn’t wear a safety vest for the first 50 years I hunted. Then I fell and cracked ribs. For six weeks it HURT to do,well, just about anything. The only advice the MD had for me was “don’t do it again.” --my kids were all 3-day riders (one still is). I always made sure they wore vests when doing o/f. I admit at first I was MORTIFIED that the vest added vastness to my silhouette.

My entire life I’ve taken pride in my slender turn out --that I looked like a potato was not a look I wanted. BUT --I sew --so I altered my hunt attire to fit neatly and properly over my vest. You might ask why I didn’t wear my vest over my hunt clothes instead of under --the view. We fox hunters love tradition – a vest over a coat, stock tie, vest would not be traditional turn out --and I’d need two. I also ride in the summer with my vest on --one big enough to fit over my attire would be too big to wear over a T shirt. Once I had all my clothes correctly tailored --I saw pictures of myself --I look ok --no one can tell I’m wearing a safety vest.

So I’m guessing jump riders don’t wear a vest because they don’t see a need. Once they’ve cracked a rib or two falling on a jump, then tried to do all the house work and farm work with painful rib bones --they may change their minds. I did.

3 Likes

Sandy Ferrel wears a vest in the hunters after suffering an injury. If someone who rides as well as she does can, so can I. 😉

8 Likes

I’m seriously thinking about getting a vest. Would love some recommendations. Currently an AA rider, hoping to do the AOs someday!

2 Likes

What kind of vest and jacket do you have?

I have a Charles Owen JL9 vest that I’m really happy with. It’s a gel/foam combination. It’s fitted so it’s more flattering as far as vests go. You’ll get warm underneath it but it’s not unbearable. I’ve evented with it when it’s 95 degrees out and humid and I was fine. You can also get custom measurements, like if you’re slim but very tall, an off-the-rack small will fit your rib cage width but won’t be long enough for your torso. I think the custom ones are the same price as the off-the-rack ones, at least they were at Dover when I bought mine in 2013.

I’ve also used the Charles Owen Kontact vest and really liked it as well.

I did not like the Airowear vests. I’m 5’2", 125 lbs, A-cup…but they were too snug in the chest region for me, which was wild because it’s not like I had much in that area to begin with? They were well made otherwise, just didn’t fit me at all.

2 Likes

I’m with you - I don’t understand that type of thing.

5 Likes

I would also argue that cost, at least for the air vests, is a huge barrier to entry. I know there is the whole “you can’t put a price on safety” and I normally agree with that - but when the starting price of some air vests is around $800-900 AND needs to be replaced after a single use (admittedly I don’t know what the cost of replacement canisters etc. are - hoping it’s lower than the initial cost), this places vests like these out of the price point for many people. Hopefully the technology will be improved to a point where they can still offer the safety but be available at a lower price point for those of us who are interested in using them but cannot currently afford to.

You only have to replace the canister if the vest goes off. A $20 item.

You can buy a vest that is not an air vest for quite a bit less than your quoted numbers. If you are interested in a vest and the safety of a vest that would probably be a good place to start.

2 Likes

I do the A/O jumpers and I wear a vest when I jump. For home I have a Tipperary and for shows I have a Dada airvest. I like the Dada because the airvest zips into an outer show coat or vest. I have the Carthago vest and two Catapulte show coats - one blue and one black. The way they’re designed, they really aren’t bulky at all, and unless you’re right up next to me you can’t tell it’s anything other than a regular technical fabric show coat. There are various outer coats, jackets and vests from Dada that the airvest can zip into. The cartridges are about $30.

3 Likes

So I commented on this 10 years ago but my opinion has drastically changed since then. Any plus sized vests on the market?

3 Likes

I used the JL9 after fracturing my ribs and it was truly a comfortable vest. I sweat like heck in it, but it also helped make me a stronger rider through the summer while I healed. I had a Hit Air vest that I used over it for jumping. When it came time to show again, which was after I healed up, I still wanted to wear a vest just in case. But I also wanted a lower profile, so I went with the Tipperary competitor. It hurt me in the Eq flat as I did look a little hunchback/postured, but it truly didn’t impact my hunter classes. Sure, I spent over $1000 in vests but I was able to keep riding and protect myself while I healed. I’ve got a friend currently showing in a Hit Air while she recovers and my only concern is that you really need a vest under the hit air for complete protection as a horse can get a hoof in between the vest. I’ve got another friend who is showing the jumpers in the Horse Pilot vest and I think she’s super smart for putting her safety first. It’s a really nice vest and is relatively low profile. I love their show coat option! It’s quite nice!

1 Like

So, I’m actually quite pleased that this old thread has come back to life. In the 10 years since I wrote this post, obviously vests are still not super popular at the shows, but I am seeing more and more riders wearing them for schooling and hacking and I think it is a great trend. My now a bit older jumper has maintained his quirky personality and I still always wear a vest when riding him.

I hope that your change of mind did not involve you getting injured. Otherwise always glad when people have open minds! FWIW, I feel like the eventing folks have a lot of good feedback about fit and comfort of different brands.

Check out Racesafe. They have a pretty extensive range of sizes and back lengths. I ordered based on the measurements I entered here and got a good fit in my ProVent 3.0 https://racesafe.co.uk/pages/fitting-guide

1 Like

I know this thread is old but I always wear my vest jumping. My coat is sized to fit it. Granted it adds 5-10lbs to my profile but I have had way to many near misses to not use it.

For those that say it’s too hot, I did this in Florida and Virginia, dry heat has nothing on heat and humidity. Hydrate my friends!

Truth. Honestly, it just doesn’t even register that I have it on after a couple minutes. I event in Area 2 so I’m in full xc gear for my stadium round.

Since the original thread is 10 years old, Tipperary redesigned their vest so that it doesn’t have that whole stick-puncture structure anymore. I replaced my old Tipperary with the new one a few years ago and it’s great.

Glad to know the canisters are not as expensive to replace. I’m interested in the safety of a vest but what appeals to me about the air vest specifically is their ability to inflate and potentially reduce whip lash/trauma to the neck and spinal cord. Most traditional vests that I’ve seen do not have that capability. While yes, they would probably be helpful if I fell on something or were stepped on, they would not be helpful in the event of a neck injury which to me is the biggest reason to get a vest in the first place.

I am old enough to remember that when I moved from the lesson mill mill barn to the show barn, I got told to ditch the harness helmet for a hunt cap. Then, in 1984, we all had to wear harness helmets again. Looking back, those helmet were laughable.

The better-protecting helmets showed up in the 90s, but pretty much no one on the circuit (other than Addison Phillips, who won plenty with it) wore one. Then one of Joe Dotoli’s students was killed in an accident and he did the hard work to challenge the helmet manufacturers to come up with helmets that fit different heads, were comfortable and looked good. We’ve been wearing then for what, 15-20 years now?

What we need is the same challenge to vest manufacturers. The motorcycle people have this down, with shirts you can zip on and off and that fit under your ballistic gear. They are much more subtle than our vests and are made with vented fabric. My husband has both the undervest and a spine protector, and I’m envious of his gear. It’s a huge deal in motorcycles for obvious reasons, but why can’t someone translate that technology?

Let’s be honest, no one does it because famous people don’t do it and it’s ugly. I wish people would own up to that.

Anyway…

Thankfully no major injuries but my priorities between ages 22 and 32 have changed significantly :wink: