Well, it took me several hours to read all these posts, and then some time to stop laughing!
I have a few unsightly horse figurines in my china cabinet (along with some nice ones too), that my mother has given me over the years, and since she comes to visit I can’t exactly send them on down the road quite yet. But they are not horrendously bad.
As to the “worst” non-horsey gifts:
Age 10 - when I weighed all of about 50 pounds - my grandmother gave me a girdle - complete with the garter straps for stockings! My mother and I still laugh about that one.
Age 14 - the year my parents divorced - Dad sent to my brother and me - a 5.00 book of McDonalds Gift certificates - and that was all.
Age 15 - Dad strikes again. This time he sends some Army patches (the calvalry and something else - he was an officer in the army at the time) and a ski mask/hat - you know, the one that pulls over your head with the eye, nose and mouth holes? I said “what the heck, does he want us to start robbing banks?”
After that he got remarried, and the gifts got a bit better, but not much, since he let my ex-stepmother be in charge of gift buying. His third wife was much, much better at gift giving, no complaints with her gifts.
Age 16 - grandmother strikes again. Red velvet slippers that looked like elf boots (came up way over your ankles) with pointy toes and black plastic soles and heels! It was all my mother and I could do to keep a straight face when I opened that box.
My ex-husband - our first Christmas together he bought me a set of TV trays (the kind you eat dinner in front of the TV on), because I had mentioned that it might be easier to use those instead of the coffee table. After that he got a list from me every year, until the divorce.
Last year - my MIL works in a western wear store, and most of the time she does okay - well, this one was a gray western style shirt, complete with the pearl snaps, and bright red roses embroidered on it both front and back! Worst part? She lives with us, and I have not had the nerve yet to put it on and wear it in public! And I can’t put it in the clothing donation bin yet (but I’m sure some square dancing folks might just drool over it!).
This year I filled out an Amazon wish list, and emailed it to my daughter, with instructions that she get a copy to my husband. He is smart enought to know to get me only what I ask for. Although what I really want is a contractor grade 100ft hose for the barn, and I am too cheap to buy it for myself, won’t it be funny if that does show up under the tree?