Yeah, that’s a good point. Obviously the penalties can’t show the difference between a round that is making an observer cringe the whole way through versus one where the horse seems to be having a decent round but just knocks every other rail.
The horse in my barn does not show any of those types of behaviors during SJ. He just doesn’t seem to respect the SJ poles the way he does a solid XC obstacle. I believe he was started as a fox hunter before the current owner started eventing with him so I wonder sometimes if that’s the reason. But it could also be a soundness or training or riding issue.
I don’t disagree with the rule, I just am not convinced it will necessarily catch all the problems. Instead of adding more rules, I really wish the officials would use more of the discretion they have to call out dangerous riding to do something about some of the truly scary rides out there.
I have twice seen a SJ judge (the same one) call riders over after a pretty hairy round and warn them that she was concerned about their lack of control and was going to tell the TD that they needed to be watched closely on the cross country course. I knew one of the riders and it did seem to be a bit of a wake up call for her. I think USEA should really be encouraging the officials to step up and be proactive about this sort of thing.