My Blundstones are my true all purpose boots. I ride in them, wear them to run errands, and wear them to feed and clean paddocks for 30-something horses at work monday through friday. Sadly my current pair are falling apart after less than a year and I am not too keen on replacing them with more sub-par blunnies…
Problem I have with paddock boots is that lace ups and zip ups tend to rub my heel/tendon I like the elastic gussets of the pull ons because they offer flexibility and allow me to get my bad ankle (with and without brace) in and out comfortably. I like the wide fit of Blunnies because they offer a bit of wiggle room and air circulation in summer, and leave space for wool socks when temperatures drop.
I do wear goretex hiking gaiters over my boots for work to keep hogfuel out of my shoes, so a slightly looser fitting upper isn’t an issue.
Being able to wear the new boots to ride is a bonus but not mandatory. Biggest thing is comfort, wiggle room, and durability.
I wear Men’s 7 Or Blundstone 5.5.