Another kind of horse welfare

A must read, especially for those showing.
https://www.chronofhorse.com/article/we-showed-on-sunday-he-died-on-tuesday-an-outbreak-story/

"What I know now is the trainers and riders of four horses, including a pretty gray showing in our classes, ignored the state veterinarian’s recommended protocols, as well as entry restrictions put in place by the LA [Los Angeles] show’s organizers, by arriving at LAEC within the seven-day window their horses should have been isolated and observed for signs of illness. "

The show organizer failed to effectively enforce the entry restrictions it had enacted to protect the horses showing at the LAEC. The trainers—one of them a U.S. Equestrian Federation judge and steward—knew. A steward’s job is to enforce the rules and sanction those breaking them. Their choices put all our horses in danger.

Thank you COTH, and Marlo Baird, for sharing the story.

17 Likes

Ugh, yeah, I read that article. Some people are so selfish and have this burning desire to compete. It gets to a point where it’s basically disgusting, IMO. That horse’s death was unnecessary in that it could’ve easily been prevented had people followed the recommended protocols. I feel so bad for Marlo and the horse’s connections/everyone involved.

14 Likes

I am sure some of us in western states have vivid nightmare memories of the EHV-1 outbreak of 2012. When an outbreak at a championship show in Utah was not understood properly while there was still time to limit exposure, there was no shutdown/quarantine before competitors began leaving to return home, and hundreds of horses from the show spread out to over 20 states and Canada.

Before that moment, most of us and many vets had never heard of EHV-1.

I first heard of it when a vet at a major clinic in our area called our barn owner/manager, knowing the barn mostly had owners who showed, and told her to lock down the barn/property. “No horses in, no horses out, until this outbreak is considered under control”. And a LOT of protocols for humans, as several of us had friends at other barns and might encounter them.

Because horses from the Utah show had returned to our county. Our barn didn’t have any horses at direct risk in that moment, but a barn-lockdown was the only way to keep it that way.

That night there was a very serious emergency meeting of any interested horse owners to hear more details from a cadre of local vets. Big crowd at a public meeting space, people looked as if they had come straight from the barn, all disciplines. Cowboy hats to endurance outfits to English breeches. It was grim. A 17 year old girl was there in tears, with her dad, she was one of the owners who had just lost her horse to EHV-1. They felt moved to come and share, in hopes of helping other horses. Her story of how that horse crashed hard and fast, how it suffered, until they euthanized, was heartbreaking. “I didn’t even have a chance to say goodbye.”

And yep, when the word went out across the western U.S. that horse shows needed to cancel, there was a resisting chorus of those who pooh-pooh’ed any risk that impeded their plans to show over the next few weeks. It even made the local news in some towns.

From the article in the first post:

What I know now is that several horses at the LA February Show had traveled directly from the Desert International Horse Park, where an outbreak of equine herpesvirus-1 that ultimately would sicken and kill horses across the state had started a week earlier. The show in the desert had been canceled that weekend because of the outbreak.

What I know now is that, as of the weekend we were showing at LAEC, eight horses at DIHP had spiked fevers and tested positive for the virus, including three that presented neurological symptoms. What I know now is that the first horse, of many, that would be euthanized after developing equine herpesvirus myeloencephalopathy, the neurological version of EHV-1, was put down at DIHP on Feb. 18—the same day the show at LAEC began.

What I know now is the trainers and riders of four horses, including a pretty gray showing in our classes, ignored the state veterinarian’s recommended protocols, as well as entry restrictions put in place by the LA show’s organizers, by arriving at LAEC within the seven-day window their horses should have been isolated and observed for signs of illness.

Nero and I stood next to the gray horse, rode next to this horse, breathed the same air as this horse, for hours. Unknowingly, I put Nero in invisible danger.

5 Likes

Sorry, if this isn’t politically correct, but every time an article like this is published, they should name the names of those trainers who were sanctioned by USEF for being responsible for spreading the virus, thus killing other peoples’ horses.

I don’t care how big the name, public shame them to make them think twice at pulling the same thing again. I’m sure whatever they donated to the USEF Equine Health Research Fund was peanuts to them.

40 Likes

I suggest that USEF has the wrong attitude towards disease control. It shouldn’t be business as usual, just a quick a slap on the wrist for a few fellow professionals, heigh ho, another day, another show. The USEF should recognize the bigger picture,
that an entire multi-million industry is put at risk by poor bio-security and low compliance. Major sanctions should be imposed on ANYONE who ignores recommended veterinary protocols for their own short term interests.

26 Likes

I agree…I think the perpetrators should be publicly recognized and hit hard financially. How does that even help a broken heart???

5 Likes

There’s a related thread on the H/J forum titled “Here From the EHV Article Archy” (?)
that identifies one of the trainers who was sanctioned.

1 Like

And if a judge/official contravened these guidelines!?!

Stripped of their licence. Or at least publicly suspended for X number of years

Tsk tsk. Not impressed that the organizing bodies are collecting the money, but not doing the work to keep our sport (and our horses) safe.

2 Likes

IIRC Cox is a h/j judge and steward.
Can USEF suspend him if he wasn’t working as a judge or steward at the show ?

Presumably a member of various showing bodies within USEF therefore subject to the same regulations as all other member. Whether or not he is working as a judge or steward at a particular show should be irrelevant. Worse, as a judge and steward he should know better than to breach veterinary protocols .

7 Likes

Proving a direct epidemiological link between horses is scientifically very unlikely, I learned from the state vet sent to assess Nero’s case.
The passage above is from the article. I am willing to bet if a vet or other official could not identify where this virus came from with 100% certainty the magazine would not publish the names. It would be too easy for someone to sue the publisher and the author.

6 Likes

Interesting point, but they still broke the protocol for the quarantine, ignoring the welfare of all horses on the property. I would not want to give my business to a trainer with such blatant disregard for equine safety. I still think they should be outed even if a direct connection to the death of specific horses can’t be proven. They broke the protocol, period, and were sanctioned by USEF for it. I don’t see how that info could be actionable, although IANAL.

6 Likes

If this article was just about the lack of bio security I would agree 100% about naming the trainers involved. But once the death of a specific horse was used to illustrate what can happen when bio security is compromised it became harder to name names. Nobody can prove beyond a doubt that the actions of those trainers caused the death of the horse in the article so naming them would be problematic from a legal stand point.

1 Like

Horse people seem to have a hard time understanding biosecurity. Even a lot of vet clinics have truly terrible biosecurity and infection management. As an extern I watched someone well respected and high up remove the standing wraps of a MRSA horse, step through the foot bath themselves, but then toss the wraps in the aisle to reroll, then go back through the foot bath but ignoring the fact that now the aisle is contaminated. I worked with pigs during grad school, where shower in shower out was the norm and biosecurity protocols required you to not step foot on any other pig farm for two weeks prior to the visit. I get that this isn’t doable in horses nor required. But don’t blatantly ignore the protocols that are in place. But people let horses share water buckets, stalls aren’t easily disinfected etc. One of my favourites was watching a barn in my area take the bedding from the outside horses that were there for a show and distribute it among all the stalls of the resident horses. It will unfortunately take a widespread outbreak of something deadly to get people to smarten up.

10 Likes

https://www.chronofhorse.com/article/thermal-wellington-to-institute-rapid-pcr-testing-to-protect-against-ehv-1/

You are 100% correct.

1 Like

BTDT. More than once. Horse people as a population are not smarter about biosecurity.

Actual outbreaks may cause some individuals to change, but not the population. The 2012 EHV-1 outbreak/scare was accompanied by widespread publicity along with weeks of shutdowns of shows and competitions across the western U.S. It was on the people-news, locally and even nationally on the networks. If that didn’t make these fundamental changes of attitude (it didn’t), no outbreak ever will.

What is needed is a marketable education effort, with some will behind it. That will format the info and keep it in front of people for an extended period. It will be a journey to do that. But it might significantly help, even if it doesn’t completely reform the industry. IMO.

1 Like

Mandatory online modules with your national membership? I don’t know how you reach other people. We had a horse in the barn on isolation and I couldn’t even convince the owner to not traipse through the rest of the barn. I looked outside at one point and she was petting my horse over the fence and I nearly killed her. I was part of an equine Canada project working on biosecurity and I think we had something like 2000 people access our website over a couple of years. No one cared enough to look at it. Pork producers have mandatory biosecurity training with inspections as part of their quality assurance certification, and as a whole they are a very complient group. Maybe something like that could work? But I have little hope at this point.

5 Likes

Not at all. It can so easily be drafted to avoid making a statement of causation.

“While it is not practical to determine from which horse [dead horse] was infected, Trainer A, Trainer B, and Riders C -E brought [named] four horses to [show] that weekend in violation of established protocol and have been sanctioned for their actions.”

8 Likes