Appeals Court Rules HISA Unconstitutional

I think race trainers should stop the bickering and lawsuits. If the sport is going to survive they’d better pull together.

https://www.bloodhorse.com/horse-racing/articles/264902/fifth-circuit-court-of-appeals-hisa-unconstitutional

3 Likes

Sounds like it will be better for lawyers then the race industry. Talk about fiddling while the fire rage… :frowning_face:

America is not a nation under the law but under the lawyers.

2 Likes

I read a good bit of the decision. The set up was unconstitutional. A non-government organization can’t do a government job. It shouldn’t be that hard for Congress to write something that will pass muster; then again something that will pass constitutional muster might not pass muster with the animal rights lobby.

Animal rights lobby—you’re joking, right?

Why yes, the animal rights lobby. Lobbyist and animal rights huckster Marty Irby takes delight in proclaiming to anyone who will listen (and some who won’t) about his role in the crafting of this garbage legislation and how HISA is the greatest achievement of his lobbying career.

I work with the FTC professionally a lot, and from the start found this very dubious. It simply isn’t something they are set up to do at present and it would require significant funding to make the whole thing work, funding that wasn’t provided. It’s, unsurprisingly, a giant mess.