Aussie Saddles: Good Idea but Poor Execution
I used Aussie saddles for several years but will never go back to them. I had bought a couple of Down Under saddles (and they weren’t cheap!) but was disappointed with how those saddles are made. Unfortunately, they are made in India and quality control is poor. One saddle was crooked, and they told me it could be readjusted. I sent it back, and it was just as crooked when it came back. They wouldn’t take it back, so I took it apart to see why it was crooked. Ends up that the tree was stapled (yes, stapled!) together and the tree was horribly off balance.
So, I stepped up to a Syd Hill saddle. Very well made, but just didn’t fit my horse. Also, they tell you that they’re comfortable, and even with the extra padded seat, I found it to be hard as a rock.
Then I found Tucker–the Laz-Y-Boy of saddles. Extremely comfortable and well made. The River Plantation provides a very deep seat that has enabled me to stay seated when I would have otherwise been ousted. I’ve had Tucker saddles for about 4 years now and absolutely love them (I have one for each of my horse). Consider the center-fire rigging (Y-style rigging).
When fitting a Tucker saddle, make sure you get the correct width based on degree angle. If you can fit a piece of 90 degree angle iron over your horse’s withers, a regular width is fine. Anything more than that is a wide or extra wide. Unfortunately, they only tell you the width in inches, not angle degrees. I found this method to be precise when communicating with the folks at Tucker about which width to purchase.
After having had a Tucker, I realized how much the overgirth did indeed bother me on the Aussie saddle. I continue to rave about my Tucker saddles even after four years.
One of the things to look for on a saddle is how many used ones you see for sale on eBay and what they sell for. You rarely see a used Tucker saddle, and when you do, they fetch a good price. That says a lot.