Barbaro’s plight casts light on other side of horse racing Updated 7/13/2006 9:14 PM ET
Dr. Dean Richardson never wavered any time he assessed Barbaro’s condition.
Since Barbaro underwent emergency surgery to treat a leg injury the horse suffered in the Preakness on May 20, Richardson, the chief of surgery at the University of Pennsylvania’s New Bolton Center, guarded any cautious optimism with the reality of the situation, saying Barbaro had a 50-50 chance of survival despite any progress the horse had been making.
On Thursday, Richardson offered another blunt and bleak assessment of the horse’s prognosis: “I’d be lying if I said it was anything but poor.”
An acute case of laminitis, a painful and difficult-to-cure hoof disease, has developed in Barbaro’s left hind foot, the opposite leg that required surgery the day after the Preakness. Laminitis took the life of Secretariat, the 1973 Triple Crown winner, in 1989.
The disease was a concern for Barbaro from the beginning because it affects horses that put too much weight on one limb because another limb is unable to hold its own weight.
Without a Triple Crown winner since Affirmed in 1978, horse racing — a sport, like boxing, that is not what it once was — craves another Triple Crown champ.
Horse racing turned out such wonderful stories in the past few years. Fans take to Funny Cide and Smarty Jones. They want to watch Afleet Alex recover from a near-catastrophic stumble on the backstretch to win the Preakness.
By most accounts, Barbaro, after his impressive Derby victory, had as good of a chance as any horse in recent years to win the Derby, Preakness and Belmont.
In a grim, foreshadowing sentence, The Washington Post’s Andrew Beyer, an astute chronicler of thoroughbred racing, wrote of Barbaro before the Preakness, “… barring some unlucky development, he is going to win the Triple Crown.”
An unlucky development, and then some. This is not supposed to happen to a Triple Crown contender. Yet, the sport is faced with the very realistic possibility that Barbaro, the Kentucky Derby winner, will not survive much longer.
No one wants a young horse euthanized. It is not often people read, see and hear about this side of horse racing. Few even know what happens when a horse breaks down in a race. We are getting an up-close and sobering look, and that’s not terrible. This is living, and this might be dying. It is life, with all its joy and all its sorrow. We don’t always choose our experiences.
In Barbaro, fans found a horse they could cheer, all the connections to the horse likable folk. Barbaro’s trainer, Michael Matz, survived and helped rescue three children in a plane crash in which 185 people died. He is a three-time Olympian in equestrian and carried the flag during the closing ceremony at the 1996 Summer Games in Atlanta.
Jockey Edgar Prado sold fruit on the streets of his native Peru as a 7-year-old. He came to the United States in the mid-1980s as a teen knowing little English and fewer people. Since then, he was won more than 5,500 races.
Owners Roy and Gretchen Jackson are humble, by almost all accounts. Nearly two weeks before the Preakness, the Jacksons stopped by the Fair Hill Training Center where Barbaro trained. They met with the five journalists who made the trip to the farm country in Elkton, Md. They enjoyed it. They were self-deprecating. They were funny. They were serious.
Asked if fate played any role in winning the Triple Crown, Roy Jackson took time before answering.
“I’m trying to spend my time enjoying this,” he said. "We just don’t know why we’ve been picked out to have this happen to us. We’re sure enjoying it and along for the ride.
“We’re not particularly superstitious or anything. I think we both have a sort of a faith in whatever you want to call it — a higher power or God – but it helps with all situations in life. As far as fate that this was meant to happen, I just don’t know. We don’t question it too much.”
This was not what they thought fate had planned for them, and yet this what fate dispensed.
Now, the Jacksons are faced with the decision that torments all animal owners: if and when to euthanize. It is an emotionally taxing decision.
Putting aside cynicism for the moment, this is not about keeping the horse alive to make money. If Barbaro survives, it is not guaranteed he will have enough strength in his hind legs to stud. Furthermore, the Jacksons probably will collect insurance money if Barbaro is euthanized.
The Jacksons have maintained from the start that this is about giving Barbaro a decent quality of life if possible. There is little reason to doubt them. It’s unlikely they would prolong his life for selfish reasons. They have grown to love and care for this horse. Most likely, so have the doctors treating and monitoring Barbaro.
Richardson, the main vet on the case, emphasized he isn’t into allowing the horse to suffer.
“We are trying all reasonable avenues,” he said. “If they don’t work, we will quit. … We are not torturing this horse. I guarantee you, no veterinarian goes into this business to inflict pain in an animal. We are trying to save his life.”
If and when the time comes, the Jacksons will know and act accordingly.
Trying to save Barbaro’s life is noble and humane. And so is euthanizing him.
***