I’ve only skimmed through today’s testimony, and not going back to read a couple thousand posts so if some of this has already been discussed I apologize.
I actually think Deininger presents better than Bilinkas. He follows trial rules better and more concise in his questioning. I also think the judge does a good job keeping order in his court and keeping the attorneys following the rules.
It’s really sad to hear the various witnesses who’ve known MB for many years and had so many good things to say about him. He kept his life together well for all those years, perhaps because his ex wife handled so many things so that he could concentrate on training and coaching? And he no longer had that. However, the witnesses weren’t intimately involved with him every day and MHG did testify that he had mental issues before LK and RG were on the scene. Like many people, he could keep his professional appearances up around all those other people and privately speak with her about his depression and other issues. I’m leaning toward temporary insanity so far based upon how people have described him before, and the week leading up to the shooting. The whole situation was such a nightmare. I think he was insane for not evicting 6 months earlier.
MB had a lot of things to stress him out - his finances, running the farm, trying to perform business duties he’s never had to do in the past, having to pay out nearly a million to his ex wife when he didn’t have a lot of liquid assets. Again, it was very poor business practice to allow LK and RG back on the farm, poor business not to have any contracts. He even told his attorney right up until the day of the shooting he didn’t want to file eviction, he just wanted to scare her into leaving. And the witness saying MB had millions of dollars, who had no real idea of MB’s financial situation and monthly bills, when obviously those were not liquid millions or he wouldn’t have bee so stressed out about finances.
So I’m wondering, if MB is found not guilty due to insanity, and based upon his appearance and demeanor in court along with how his mental state was so diminished leading up to the shooting, wouldn’t it be better for him to be checked into a mental facility to get the help it appears he needs? If he’s just turned loose back into society, what if he falls apart very easily again because now he’s lost so much more than simply having a bad boarder, has paid over $600,000 in legal fees, etc. Who’s to say he won’t black out again, if that’s what happened, and go violent on someone else. Mental health is a real problem in this country (and many others) and part of the problem is that people don’t get the mental health treatment they desperately need, as so evidenced in this entire situation. (MB not the only person with mental health issues)
There are and have been millions of people who go through horrific domestic problems, such as divorce and custody cases, where the couple or other people are driving each other insane and ruining each other financially - worse than a problem boarder would be in my opinion. If people could get off with murder or attempted murder and simply set free after such an event without some kind of confinement in a a mental facility in order to get help, we’d be seeing many more violent situations that could be explained or excused away with an insanity verdict.