Barn pricing prefab vs builder

I accidentally posted this in horse care, but Around the Farm is more appropriate so this is cross posted :slight_smile:

Can someone give me some pricing estimates for building a small 4 stall center aisle barn or 3 stall shed row via contractor vs prefab? I know the cost of the building itself for prefab, but I have no idea what I’d be looking at for site prep for a prefab or what construction costs would be if I chose to build.

I have no frame of reference. I’m in the North East and I know pricing can vary based on our terrain etc, but I am really only looking for a rough estimate.

All I can come up with is a pretty much constant that has been constant at least for many decades …whatever you think it will cost it will actually cost between at least twice to three times what you thought unless you enter this project with a hard set number in a well drawn contract with a set time frame that contains a time overrun penalty

The Northeast is big place… there are Amish who often specialize in barns, then are special companies such as Morton then small time builders who may be locally specific.

Saying “Building a Barn” is very general, develop a specific outline of just what you want not a generalize thought

Hey there! I’ve been casually shopping around for barns. I’m in the Deep South so my prices may be way different than yours. I’ll be going the pole barn route most likely ( unless I can swing concrete block construction). To get the shell put up (poles and roof) I’m looking at 4-5 per square foot. This is the advertised going rate in my area. Roof insulation will be extra. Site prep is wildly dependent on the starting surface. My proposed building site is flat, red clay, already drains relatively well, no trees, close to a quarry and close to the road access on the property. I estimate that site prep would run about 5 grand for this if I hired it out. Way more expensive if not close to a quarry (or dirt pit), not flat already, or any in a spot with drainage problems (like site is at the bottom of a hill). My estimate does not include any stone, dust, gravel, etc. Just raised and graded clay pad.

Other factors at play in my area: permitting is cheap and easy here, lots of contractors that build pole barns and do dirt work available, good availability of local building products, and workable winter weather ( lots of farmers do construction type work in “winter”)

Proposed barn size is 36x24 (center aisle set up) with a lean to (overhang) on one short side OR 24x48 set up as a 4 stall shedrow with 12 ft overhang.

Building cost for a metal frame or a prefab would be more expensive in my area. I presume site prep would be similar for most building types. Except some of those Amish built modular barns might need concrete pillars? Not too sure on those, the shipping would be crazy to get one here so I haven’t investigated those much.

Hey there! I’ve been casually shopping around for barns. I’m in the Deep South so my prices may be way different than yours. I’ll be going the pole barn route most likely ( unless I can swing concrete block construction). To get the shell put up (poles and roof) I’m looking at 4-5 per square foot. This is the advertised going rate in my area. Roof insulation will be extra. Site prep is wildly dependent on the starting surface. My proposed building site is flat, red clay, already drains relatively well, no trees, close to a quarry and close to the road access on the property. I estimate that site prep would run about 5 grand for this if I hired it out. Way more expensive if not close to a quarry (or dirt pit), not flat already, or any in a spot with drainage problems (like site is at the bottom of a hill). My estimate does not include any stone, dust, gravel, etc. Just raised and graded clay pad.

Other factors at play in my area: permitting is cheap and easy here, lots of contractors that build pole barns and do dirt work available, good availability of local building products, and workable winter weather ( lots of farmers do construction type work in “winter”)

Proposed barn size is 36x24 (center aisle set up) with a lean to (overhang) on one short side OR 24x48 set up as a 4 stall shedrow with 12 ft overhang.

Building cost for a metal frame or a prefab would be more expensive in my area. I presume site prep would be similar for most building types. Except some of those Amish built modular barns might need concrete pillars? Not too sure on those, the shipping would be crazy to get one here so I haven’t investigated those much.

so I check Hansen Pole Buildings which also sold through Home Depot, Hansen has a generalized pricing estimator for the Building itself

[URL=“https://www.hansenpolebuildings.com/pole-barn-prices/”]https://www.hansenpolebuildings.com/pole-barn-prices/

https://www.homedepot.com/p/44-ft-x-40-ft-x-18-ft-Wood-Garage-Kit-without-Floor-Project-10-0813/300225492?source=shoppingads&locale=en-US&mtc=Shopping-B-F_D21-G-D21-21_3_DIMENSIONAL_LUMBER-Generic-NA-Feed-LIA-NA-NA-&cm_mmc=Shopping-B-F_D21-G-D21-21_3_DIMENSIONAL_LUMBER-Generic-NA-Feed-LIA-NA-NA--71700000045530102-58700004682521920-92700053361644927&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI16mvm8vj6wIVip6zCh0RQwuwEAQYAyABEgJCl_D_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

We had a barn building company build a 36x48 with 16’ overhangs on both sides, 4 stalls, tack room and large feed/hay room, roughly $75,000 when it was all done, that included a lot of customized things.

Second time around we bought a premade shed row, 4 stalls, $18,000 delivered and set up. Still not cheap but it was delivered ready to go.

Hey there! I’ve been casually shopping around for barns. I’m in the Deep South so my prices may be way different than yours. I’ll be going the pole barn route most likely ( unless I can swing concrete block construction). To get the shell put up (poles and roof) I’m looking at 4-5 per square foot. This is the advertised going rate in my area. Roof insulation will be extra. Site prep is wildly dependent on the starting surface. My proposed building site is flat, red clay, already drains relatively well, no trees, close to a quarry and close to the road access on the property. I estimate that site prep would run about 5 grand for this if I hired it out. Way more expensive if not close to a quarry (or dirt pit), not flat already, or any in a spot with drainage problems (like site is at the bottom of a hill). My estimate does not include any stone, dust, gravel, etc. Just raised and graded clay pad.

Other factors at play in my area: permitting is cheap and easy here, lots of contractors that build pole barns and do dirt work available, good availability of local building products, and workable winter weather ( lots of farmers do construction type work in “winter”)

Proposed barn size is 36x24 (center aisle set up) with a lean to (overhang) on one short side OR 24x48 set up as a 4 stall shedrow with 12 ft overhang.

Building cost for a metal frame or a prefab would be more expensive in my area. I presume site prep would be similar for most building types. Except some of those Amish built modular barns might need concrete pillars? Not too sure on those, the shipping would be crazy to get one here so I haven’t investigated those much.

Shedrow barns are always considerably cheaper, but you get what you pay for, a regular structure they are not.

A real barn is enclosed from the weather and you can open it up as your weather demands, as much as you provide for.
To open it up you use doors, windows and air flow exchange techniques.

A shedrow barn is not a real barn, is exposed to the elements, is really a shed.

Both have their place, just different purposes.

When it comes to price, it is hard to compare, as they are not going to serve the same needs.

3 Likes

I had this nice detailed post typed up, tried to edit it after posting, and now it is in unapproved limbo. Alas.

The short version: $4-5 per square foot for pole barn shell (roof and poles only), same range for site prep on existing flat, well drained, no trees, clay soil area, same range again for poured concrete (maybe a bit cheaper for concrete).

This is for my location in the Deep South where permitting is cheap and easy.

I had a modular 34x36 center aisle brought in/built last year. I also had quotes from pole barn builders, but since I wanted a loft they weren’t particularly competitive in comparison to the modular companies. I spent about $55k on the barn excluding site prep, electric, etc. If I had been able to go without a loft it would have saved me about $15k and possibly made a pole barn more economical. My barn is basic, unpainted for right now, and the aisle is stonedust until I find more money lol.

Lumber is way up in price right now, so I’m assuming prices are up.

In the Florida panhandle I paid $2200 for my pad last fall. I went with a 36x36 barn with Morton for around $64k. Keep in mind I went with the high rib steel, a cupola, 2 Dutch doors, had them put in 2 stalls & had them handle the concrete for the center aisle & where the side door is. I signed my contract during their discount days & got 15% off. I think that starts in October now.

You really need to contact a builder for pricing because there are so many variables. My sales rep was fantastic. He came with his boss for the initial visit & they worked with me & advised ways to keep the cost down. Dutch doors are expensive but that wasn’t something I would go without.

Everything is expensive once it all adds up. My 70x30 run with limestone screenings was probably another $8k & I’ve spent another $4200 just on lumber for the run out & a pasture a little over an acre.

1 Like

Depending on all the variables that go into selecting a site, site prep can have a fairly wide range. That for me is the wildcard here. Choosing to stick frame it or bring in modular would have numbers that are constants. Site prep is anything but that.

Thanks - this is super helpful, since no matter what I do not want a loft. I already have a couple quotes for modular buildings. I have a small shedrow that I am looking to replace/expand, so I suspect if I do an exact shedrow replacement, or even just slightly expanded, my site prep won’t probably be astronomical.

I really just have no idea what to expect even ball park for site prep and if I were to go modular, I have a hard time understanding whether or not a modular barn delivery would even fit up my driveway.

Lots of variables to consider. If you were to work with a barn builder it’s just like working with a home builder - the price per square foot depends on how elaborate your finishes are. Concrete areas, tongue and groove walls, electric, plumbing, overhangs, materials . . . You’re probably looking at $40-$50 for a nicely equip barn, but there are lots of builders who could build a basic shell and you could finish things off the way you want slowly.
I’m probably paying around $45/sqft for a barn we’re building now but I have a lot of upgrades like hated/ cooled tack with bathroom, wash stall, tongue & groove throughout, concrete center aisle, 12ft over hang, 9/12 roof pitch. The higher roof pitch means more materials for framing and roof. So that does make a difference.

Too many variables. Call a barn builder in the area (Circle B Barns, Center Hill Barns, Horizon Structures, the Barn Yard, Morton Buildings) and send them a picture of several examples of what you want, along with pictures of your site (including the driveway) and have each of them give you an estimate. Then budget for double that.

Thanks for the advice! I have already contacted a couple builders, but there are only a handful in the area and I’m having trouble with scheduling them to come out. I’m mostly trying to get a sense of what to expect before I get my first quote.

I think low estimates and high estimates should be red flags and if I only get one or two quotes I don’t know what to expect. I’ll probably call a sales rep at horizon this week. Too bad the equine affaire isn’t happening this year! I think I could have considered buying the demo barn from horizon! The little backyard barns are exactly what I want!

When my husband and I bought our first property, we knew we wanted to restore one of the old outbuildings and build out stalls. I had Morton come out and do an estimate for us to see what they thought about working with a pre-existing structure. The guy thought we were better off building new, saying that it would likely cost upwards of 50-60k. Afterwards, I was crushed… I knew Morton was expensive, but hearing it straight shattered my naivete. :lol:

We then worked with a local contractor in our rural area, who thought he could certainly work with what we had. He wasn’t necessarily a barn builder, but could build just about anything (that’s how it works in our area). We had the area excavated around the barn to put in nice footing for the sacrifice paddock. We had the barn poles reinforced, reskimmed with new siding and rooftop, replaced barn doors, cut out windows, poured concrete aisle, and built out an overhang on one side for the paddock, so we had to learn quickly about how to make final design decisions. Probably spent upwards of 20-25k. Then my husband built our stalls and windows, which ended up looking great and saved us so much money in labor. We have a lot of great memories now of getting this place horse-ready together, without necessarily breaking our backs by trying to do everything.

In my experience, the dirt work (building the pad), electrical, plumbing, concrete work, insulation, etc., were half the cost of our barn build. In other words, those other items doubled the cost of our MD barn. It’s modular, but panels are bolted together, and the barn roofed on site; it’s not delivered in one or two pieces, so hauling it up our driveway was not an issue.

We were responsible for the dirt work, done to the barn company’s specifications, and we used their concrete guy for the footings and the aisle (having the latter paved was an option we wanted), but maybe we could have had someone else do the concrete work.

We had a dirt guy come out and shoot our prospective site with a laser level, and he gave use an estimate of how much rock we needed for the site – the pad has to be larger than the barn, all the way around. We changed our minds about the location when it came time to do the work, and his new estimate was a little less. In the end, it didn’t require as much rock, so the final cost actually came in lower than the estimate. We didn’t have a challenging site.

Just having the guys show up to do the dirt work – bringing in the earth moving equipment, the water truck, the roller, and crew – is a chunk of change, so we took advantage of their being at our place to have them spruce up our driveway (which they had originally installed years earlier). So, if any other such work needs to be done, it might be worth pricing out what it would cost, to take advantage of the crew and equipment already being on site.

I’ve had bids ranging from $46k for a 36 x 36 shell and nothing else to $120k 36 x 48’ w 1 overhand (finished). 3 different companies. The most expensive and the cheapest were Morton (w me changing what was included). Lumber is up 30% this year per my builder friends.

Lumber is not the only supply. EVERYTHING is up 20-60%. See my post in “Building A Barn”. Another neighbor to my west just built a new house last year. Finishing the basement this year, he said pre-cut 2X4s went from $3 each last year to $6, and 7/16 drywall went from $8/sheet to $24.