I own a few bridles from Bartville. If you are having something repaired, emphasize show quality or they will not worry about matching leather. If you are buying a bridle, they tend to run big so we always ask for cob size cheek pieces- regular bridle with cob cheek pieces seems to fit right.
That being said, the quality is excellent. I have a bridle that I bought as a show bridle in about 2004 and has been relegated to a schooling bridle for two to three horses at a time. It is cleaned maybe two or three tines in the summer and pretty much never in the winter. The leather is still soft and it is in very good condition.
My boa k show dressage bridle, light chestnut show bridle and light chestnut with blue trim show bridle are all Bartville. Pretty much the entire barn has at least the two Colorado custom bridles and most of my trainer’s bridles are Bartville.
Some custom girths came from there as well.
Price plus quality is definitely worth it.