In the last few years all I’ve worn have been my Tuccis. I have the Marilyns (the ones with patent leather accents) and the Harleys, and I adore both of them. I think they are by far my most flattering boots and have lasted the longest looking the nicest out of all of the brands I have.
I also have several pairs of Deniros. I lived in their tennis-shoe-sole boots for a long time, and absolutely loved them, but they definitely aged worse than the Tuccis, and I’d get 18-24 months out of them before they were trashed.
Friends say that their Parlantis don’t last terribly long, but people seem to love them nonetheless. And I’ve heard great things about LM boots. I have old Sergio Grassos and they held up well and looked nice, but I never thought they were quite tall enough, so hard to give much of an opinion since that’s more of a boot measuring thing than anything related to the brand.
Also have Fabbris, and have really liked them. But they came to me used, so I don’t know how the break-in process really went, and they’re not as flattering, but that’s not saying much since they weren’t actually made for me. Certainly worth a look.
At the end of the day I think that they’re all relatively equal and it just comes down to which ones fit you the best. I know my exact size in Tuccis, so probably will stick with them until I don’t fit into the off the shelf boots anymore, lol!