Best Rain Coats?

Hi all!
I’ve had a pikeur rain coat for three or so years that I adored, but the buttons are slowly starting to come off. I’m starting to look around for a new one and before I buy a new one, I’m looking for suggestions.
I’d like it to come in neutral colors (black, navy etc.), be flattering and be about as durable and at least as waterproof,i t doesn’t have to be a riding brand, I would like a packable hood and for it to be wearable while riding.
Thanks in advance!
(this is the raincoat I had before)

I have this jacket and like it very much.

http://www.nobleoutfitters.com/products/pinnacle-jacket

My jacket is actually a lot more flattering than the model picture. I suspect she wore it a size too big. Only thing is the hood isn’t packable. It does unbutton and can be removed, but doesn’t store in itself.

I love my Asmar jacket. I know they’re pricy, but they’re wonderful!

I drool over the Asmar jackets weekly.

I would haunt the Eddie Bauer, LL Bean, and LandsEnd sites. Their rain coats are really well made and flattering. When the coats go on closeout, you can get a deal.