[QUOTE=aktill;6401032]
Conversely something like a spade, even with a tall port, offers so much surface area that it’s comparatively much less pressure in any one given area and in some ways can be considered much less “harsh”.[/QUOTE]
Anyone using a Spade bit as you describe, pulling and spreading out the pressure, shouldn’t be allowed to have the bit!
It isn’t surface area that lets the Spade bit work well, it is balance and TRAINING of the horse. Training a horse to wear a Spade bit is nothing that happens fast. Those skilled horses work with barely a lift of the reins and pulling on them is a nasty thing to do with the Spade bit in their mouth. They don’t need the pull to respond if well trained, just the touch or lifted rein.
Not all horses going into the training, will reach the level of skill needed to wear the Spade bit well. Those less skilled horses need to be wearing another style bit other than a Spade bit of any design.