The world is diverse, there are all kinds of people and with their own motivations out there.
There are also all kinds of horse breeders and for a good number of them, the main reason breeding in general exists, is to breed to improve the breed and have better offspring than their parents.
We can’t work at breeding without goals and ideas and following bloodlines has always been important, is one way to breed better, to know what you may have in each individual according to their bloodlines, as just thinking is a good one, let’s make more like it is not enough when breeding, misses so much more than breeding is.
That is why it matters that papers follow all, as many as you can have, the more the more accurate we can be as breeders, avoiding pitfalls.
The western world has been very good at that, can measure what is good or not so good because bloodlines matter, certificates with each horse, as many as possible, matter for that goal.
Is how diseases were found, like HPPY and HERDA and others, then up to the breeders to use that information to become better breeders.
To glibly dismiss registration certificates for horses is just being shortsighted when it comes to the importance that breeding records are to our horses, all the many kinds of horses we have.
Don’t let being perfect, keeping track of every one individual, not so easy in the real world, impossible, be used to dismiss the importance of trying to know as much as we may from as many as we can, as breeders, about the horses we breed.