Fabriano for calm, Escudo II for smart
We have two 2012 foals by Fabriano. Both have been easy so far and have given us every reason to expect this will continue.
The first Fabriano get is a filly out of a 2009 Londonderry/Santano/Grandduell mare. This mare was bred by us, and is the mount of our 15 year old. The mare is talented but could be more self assured. Her filly by Fabriano looks to have at least as much potential but with a much more secure demeanor.
Our second get of Fabriano is a colt (now gelded) out of a Tb mare. This mare tends to worry. With this colt we again got improvements on the mare including a secure demeanor.
For comparison, we also have two Escudo II fillies (2010 and 2011) out of a Harper (trak) mare. The dam is smart, calm and highly self assured.
Both of our Escudo II fillies are scary smart. The older has been in training for a few months. She is a favorite of those who interact with her for any length of time. She wants so badly to please that she is prone to showing frustration if she doesn’t understand what is expected of her. The trainer has been high on her from the first days in training. However, the trainer has cautioned that the filly tries so hard that she needs a rider who will appreciate her efforts even when she has misinterpreted the aids. Time will tell with the second Escudo II filly, who will go to training in a few months.
We like both fillies by Escudo II, but I’d give the nod to Fabriano when the only criterion is calmness. If looking for intelligent, Escudo II should be on your list. In our experience, Escudo II has not added height while Fabriano has.
Note: Add high intelligence to a willing mare. High intelligence without willingness is a different challenge than most of us seek.