[QUOTE=Guin;8045214]
My current Pembroke is docked but if I’m ever insane enough to get another one, I will insist on the breeder leaving the tail alone.[/QUOTE]
Good luck finding a breeder that will leave a typically docked litter undocked. They should be done at such an early age (2-3 days) that they are unlikely to leave one undocked in hopes that YOU will still want that puppy at 8 weeks. Maybe you will, but a breeder that is trying to meet the AKC breed standard is unlikely to leave one long and hope that nothing will fall through.
I own a docked-tail breed and am really indifferent to the whole docking process. I know of many hunting breeds that have tails that are plagued with tail injuries…in fact, I learned of how to keep a tail safe on Facebook from a pointer person - there is a whole protocol for keeping pointer tails from being broken, and how to manage them when they break (not if).
In Europe, there is some backlash about the banning of docking tails in hunting and working breeds because of tail injuries. So…to be truly honest…if the only thing someone don’t like about a breed is a docked tail…ehh…talk to someone that has had a broken tail and see if that is better. If not…maybe not a big enough issue to really draw a line in the sand.
Same with dewclaws – I have had two friends with adult dogs and multiple dewclaw tears. They ended up having the dewclaw removed at adult ages because of the problems.
Ears…that’s another story - purely cosmetic in most cases. But tails? There are some real reasons for docking the tails of certain breeds.