Chewy has been really good to me. I’ve been using them for about three years now with no issues except for one dented can shipment (detailed below).
I used to order food for my sister’s cat because I already had a Chewy account for my own, and we couldn’t get the food she needed locally. When the cat unexpectedly died, I tried to cancel the order but it had already gone through. I contacted them asking if there was any way they could cancel the order and/or I could send it back for a refund - they said no, it was past catching, but they refunded me in full, and asked me to donate the food to a local shelter. I brought it to the donation bin at Petsmart.
When I ordered a 24ct of Weruva canned wet food for my cat with sundry issues, the cans arrived damaged - some were even perforated. In shades of East Of Eden, I refuse to feed dented cans in general due to botulism risks. I contacted them asking if there was any way I could return and buy a new one at a slight discount since it looked like it was just damaged in transit (the box was also pretty worn), and they said not to bother returning, and sent me a replacement for free on overnight, and told me to just dispose of the cans. I felt awful throwing them away VS donating but didn’t want to risk it!
I really like them. I think if you message them you might be pleasantly surprised!