Confessions of a "Perch-er"

My name is DebS and I perch.
I am on the road to recovery (in less than 12 steps), here is my testimonial.

Step 1. Recognizing there’s a problem is half the battle.
None of my instructors or riding buddies told me I perched. I did hear “sit up” a lot, and then I started to hear “relax” a lot because I was working so hard at “sitting up” that I became “stiff” from trying so hard… Suddenly, I couldn’t get a decent canter depart and lessons became a source of frustration. And so began a cycle of confused riding. I realized I needed help.

Step 2. Bring a camera/camcorder to the barn.
The camera doesn’t lie. One picture may not tell the whole story, but a whole roll gets pretty close and the video tape, besides adding 5 pounds, is brutally honest. I showed the pics to a rider friend at work who uttered those fateful words “Oh, you’re perched!”
The Horror.

Step 3. No bad horses
Now, we all know, we can’t blame the horse.
I do think less-than-forward school horses compound the problem, but the fault lies with the rider.
I do think educated and willing school horses will help fix the problem, as long as the rider works hard.

Step 4. Instructors
The kind of instructor you have can help or hinder the percher.

“The Natural” Sometimes the nicest riders make the poorest instructors. Particularly someone who’s “a natural”. These are the ones who are gifted with balance and feel. Great for them, not necessarily good for the student. They can’t always articulate what you’re doing wrong and how to correct it. They “just do it”, why can’t you? This can be a frustrating, demoralizing experience for the percher. As nice as they may be, it might benefit you to find someone else.

“Back to Basics”. Then there’s the instructor who will not let you progress until you get it right. This is not a particularly bad thing, as long as they’re actually helping you to improve and not just waiting for you to “get it”. Repeating the same lessons/mistakes over and over again. Some students recognize the futility of this type of training after 3 lesson, some after 3 years. But all of them usually move on toÂ…

“A Good Match”. This is an instructor who can communicate with you, has a good eye, and tries different methods for you to improve. You stick with them, see and feel the difference and just about “get it” but…you still need some fine tuning to allow you to progress furtherÂ…and you search outÂ…

“Centered Riding” I’ve read the book, I can visualize with the best of them, but until I actually took a lesson with a certified instructor, I was missing a big piece of the puzzle. There’s so much more to correcting perching than just sitting up. You really need to retrain your muscles, understand how your bones and joints hang together, breath, relax, focus and unfocus and all kinds of neat things that just improve your balance. An open mind is necesssary and mirrors help, too.

Step 5. Better horses

Now that you’ve improved your seat and balance you need to validate your progress. Find a horse that is confirmed in its gaits and likes its job. Get the feel of “What’s Right”. Really ingrain that feeling in your body and mind. This takes a lot of time, but unlike the “back to basics” instructor, you’re repeating the correct things and not the incorrect over and over. It feels soooo much better.

Now you can go back and ride the more challenging horses because you have an idea of what you want to achieve.

That’s about it. It only takes a few years, some soul searching, lots of reading and money. Good luck to all those perchers out there. You’re not alone.

[This message has been edited by DebS (edited 11-24-2000).]

[This message has been edited by DebS (edited 11-24-2000).]

I’m Thoroughbred_33 and I pinch my knees horribly.

This is due to my first trainer screaming ‘hold him with your knees! Your knees keep you on!’ and I took it to a fine point. I’m slowly getting better … my lower leg looks better all the time.

TB_33

My name is Splendid and I ride crooked…I think it started as a result of an old fall and now I ride with my right shoulder forward, hence I’m always fiddling with my reins instead of straightening out.

Oh yeah, and I canter with my head tilted in the direction I’m going, causing my outside shoulder to go forward, causing me to lose contact with my outside rein, causing my horse to bulge at the shoulder, causing us to break into a trot.

I could go on, but I’ll spare you the details. I’ve been in recovery for one year now and keep fixing one thing only to find something else that needs work! Oh the agony…

My name is VTrider and I pinch at the knee and can’t do a sitting trot wihtout my leg coming back and kicking my butt to save my life.

I love this “confessional” topic!!

Come one come all to repent of your riding sins.

My name is Flash44. I…

Lean forward as we get closer to the jump. No wonder my horse “feels” his way around the course.

Slouch

Can’t sit the trot WITH stirrups. They bounce off my feet.

I like my current trainer. He makes me do things I never thought possible. My body reminds me of this the morning after each lesson.

Yes, yes and more Yes. (a worthy digression)

A lot of my leaning forward/perching was due to using so much leg. Someone had to tell me, he’s jsut not listening to you, try this…followed by what you’ve just described with the dressage whip… and my life has been a whole lot easier.

My leaning has decreased substantially and my legs and gluts are much more relaxed, allowing for better feel. Plus, having a forward horse makes everything that much easier. (I <gulp> have jumped with a dressage whip)

The key to relaxing my knee (to stop pinching) was to stabilize my pelvis and relax/open-up my hips. Gravity takes care of my ankles and I allowed my joints to loosen up. The CR instructor was very helpful in this.

Still need to strengthen my lower leg, but I’m reduced to riding one day a week, so that will take a LOOOOONNNNGGGG time.

My name is Palisades and I ride with my leg a foot in front of me.

I used to think I just had a really bad leg…then I noticed that no matter who gets on my horse (including my “leg chronically too far behind her” friend), the same thing happens. I think my horse has just got a funny barrel.

Then there’s the round shoulder thing…definetly my fault, not my horse’s. I’m now in an exercise program because my back muscles have atrophied from rounding my shoulders to compensate for my spine (which is crooked) and now I can’t straighten them up without stretching them out to proper length first. Wow, I’m a little screwed up, eh?

I have a really weird problem that I have never seen anyone else do… When the spot is tight, I fade to one side to make it fit better. Really can mess up a line or a turn. I know I do it, I can see it coming and do it anyway no matter how much screaming my trainer does. Even my non-riding father says why do you jump off to one side?

Hi… My name is RF, and I make horrible faces when I see a distance. I also round my shoulders, and am a WORLD CHAMPION knee pincher over any jump that comes my way. My therapist tells me that I am not ready to talk about the faults of my eq on the flat… especially in reference to the sitting trot. She says, that in a few years, with daily counseling and a good blindfold when standing at the ring watching people with acceptable eq, I should recover and possibly lead a normal life.

[This message has been edited by RumoursFollow (edited 11-28-2000).]

My name is Louise, and I also pinch at the knees. I lead with my right shoulder, cannot keep my reins from growing and (oh the horror) I slouch.

I also love to lean forward as we approach the jump. Then I make a big move and jump up the horse’s neck on takeoff, even if we are deep!! I told my coach it would be a lot easier if I just put the saddle on the horse’s neck to start with!

Ooops, Blinky, that “yes” was not aimed at you! It was for Cactuskate.

I think a toe out can bring your calf closer to your horses sides and bring your knees out. Unless you only turn your toe out at the ankle and then it might make your knee pinch.

(I’m trying this with my leg as I sit at my desk)

My name is Aleesha and I love to carry my hands horizontally. Oh and I CAN’T see distances to jumps under like 2’9"

Aleesha

Hi my name is Morgangal and I like this confession topic! I CANNOT keep my fingers closed, I hold my right hand higher than the other, and I tend to throw my body foward and my reins away when I ask for a canter. Grrr. Luckily, I am taking lessons with an excellent trainer, and the leaning foward/throwing away reins problem is almost resolved.

Hi my name is 3ème and I fake my way through flat lessons. I don’t really know how to do things like haunches in, when to use an opening rein, etc. I just make it up as I go along and, when in a group, hide in the corners.

Oh…and…hi my name is 3ème and I have massive, hopeless, pathetic, CRUSH on my last coach… oh I need help…

My name is RagsRules and I round my back, keep my hand horizontal, and have no release.

Ryan

Hello, my name is Cactuskate and I clutch on my horse and don’t trust him.

My goal is to allow myself to breathe and ride my horse and not panic when his ears go forward and he just wants to look at something.

I feel with good “group session” such as this I can cure my panics. I really need you guys and feel you are out there for me.

It’s just me too…

A month ago it was relaxing in the middle.

Now I tend to push with my shoulders…ya, like that tells the horse anything…lol…am fixing it though.

I am so glad that I have such an excellent trainer that not only tells me what is wrong, but tells me how to fix it! And if she pushes me I know it is because she knows I can do it.

As for the sitting trot, it is hard with shorter stirrups and a forward (hunter) seat. I don’t know if you can get away with it for eq, but sit up strait and roll your bum under…ie, sit on your pockets. It not just that simple, but those are the words that helped me get it figured out.

I know this is a little weird, but we dropped my irons down to dressage length for one lesson (felt like I had spagetti legs jumping) but it made a big difference in my riding position and I’ve only brought them up a little since then…(I am not jumping big yet…just pushing 3’)…and it is really helping my overall position.

Now if I can just get the distance right every time. (When I was riding before it was a cute 14.3hh part arab, and now big, long strided, 16+hh tb…what an adjustment!)

My name is Michelle and I shove with my seat and upper body when I see the long distance. When I get anxious approaching a single fence I “count” with my hands, bouncing them up and down with each stride. And my leg slips back over the fence something awful. As punishment for my sins I’m gonna be tormented with lots of 2 point for the next 2 months!!!

I confess I was trying to think of a fault. I do sit back, my hands are low, I can sit the trot even the medium and extended with the current horse though that took a year to accomplish and he can still bounce me out. My fault is collapsing through the middle-not a slouch,but not holding the abdominals tight and keeping my ribcage up and pushing my shoulders down and relaxing my upper arm so I don’t get into a pulling contest.