I just received one and I absolutely love it - it does come a little lighter but will certainly take oil to darken it. I have greased mine about 2x and it is significantly darker. It came the same color as my new stirrup leathers and both has darken significantly with 2 greasings
I got the wide noseband hunter bridle. The noseband isn’t significantly huge - 1" - and so while it still looks wide, it isn’t extremely wide. I believe this will look great on a majority of horses
The padded crown piece is absolutely lovely. The leather is beautiful and will definitely soften up after a few rides.
Personally, I owned an Edgewood and I sold it because I was afraid it wasn’t going to last. While it was stunning, I didn’t need it at the time.
I fall in the middle of the “leather” quality - sometimes I feel like the less-nice leather will last longer. This leather is extremely nice but you can tell it will certainly hold up. I wouldn’t hesitate to buy.