[QUOTE=Plumcreek;7142244]
I live in a dry climate and oil the back side of my western saddle leather. I don’t care if it darkens as I hate light leather and do not show in classes where leather shade matters. I once looked at a saddle Bob Loomis had for sale at Congress, and it was as soft and pliable as English tack. Made a big impression on me.[/QUOTE]
My 1980 tooled-to-high-heaven MacPherson has been cared for as I do English tack. It has darkened from its medium oil (OK with me), due to neatsfoot oiling. It is dang soft and no cracking leather anywhere.
Recently, I was accused of over-oiling it by a local (western) saddle repair person. I will admit that after I clean, oil and then seal it with something like Blackrock, the saddle seems a tad sticky. But if I let it sit for a couple of days, I can do this once a year and the saddle stays just about as soft as my English tack.
Her favorite is to put Feibing’s Tan-Kote on western saddles once they have been cleaned. No ingredients on the label, so I can’t tell what it is. I get the sense that it’s an alcohol-based shellac kind of thing. It makes them shiney.
I can’t believe that’s the plan-- never send oil to the inside of the leather and seal it out. I don’t see how leather can last if you do that. Isn’t one consigning it to a thirsty death?