Devon Fall Classic Accident - Update

Forgive me for posting this way, but as I have talked to a number of folks about a variety of things I have found that MANY people knew about my accident and were horrified but didn’t know it was me or what the outcome was.

So as a means of assuring the H/J world at large who cared, I wanted to post to explain.

As far as what actually happened to me, this is the rundown.

I came to the ring to see how long before I needed to be on. I was mercifully dressed and wearing my helmet. The class was on the 5 yr old jumpers. I saw some friends by the in gate and was talking to them as I stood outside the in gate in the general chute area. The horse in the ring dropped it’s rider over on the far side of the ring. She took the bridle off as she fell. It became entangled in the horse’s hind legs. He ran loose with tail up and he galloped around towards the in gate at high speed. He never slowed down. Instead he jumped out at speed and hit me in the air. For those familiar with the in gate at Devon, he actually jumped at an angle and cleared the pvc fenceline perpendicular to the ring gate before falling on landing. I’m told that I was trying to wave him off and that I realized far too late that I was trapped. I (reportedly) tried to lean to the right to avoid the blow and he hit my left side and I fell onto my right side. I am unsure what cut my brow but it made a flap pf loose skin and a lot of blood. My husband, God love him, went to my side on the ground and instinctively held my neck still while everyone waited for 911 to be called and the ambulances to come.

I have no memories after parking my rig until I was in the ER. I had had the CT and been stitched while I was unable to recall things. So a while.

  1. By all accounts I am fine. I am not yet cleared to ride again but it’s only been 15 days. The injuries sustained were a lacerated brow (15 stitches), a concussion, and a minor rotator cuff injury. I spent 1 full day in the hospital and then was released.

  2. While there was a lot of blood, I am told, I want to assure everyone that head wounds really do bleed a ton and that in fact my stitches are out, scabs and bruising are gone and beyond a new scar neatly against my eye brow line, I look as normal as I can. You can see my most recent pic here: https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10156701798767759&set=p.10156701798767759&type=3&theater

  3. Since I have had many concussions (@10) in my life I am doing extended Physical therapy and Occupational therapy through Bryn Mawr rehab. (The same place that helped Lee Lee Dutton and Silva Martin, and many others) I am VERY fortunate to have these amazing facilities close by and blessed that my employer based insurance helps to cover a lot of the costs. I am loving the challenges that each provides and my therapists are fabulous. Moreover science and medicine have come a long way since my last concussion (2010) and realistically it’s possible that some of these methods are helping to heal some older issues left over from when they didn’t really offer rehab for minor concussions.

  4. I have a regular neurologist since I want to take care of my poor brain so I have had a visit with him and a follow up MRI of my brain. I didn’t hold still enough for the CT at the hospital so the images are largely useless and fuzzy. Since we have a past MRI of my brain from 2016 he and I decided it was much better to be safe and re-image than sorry. I did that yesterday, I haven’t heard results yet.

  5. Bear with me but I am alive because I was fortunate enough to have been wearing my helmet, and for the fact that my helmet is a Trauma Void with MIPS technology. I am now forever going to recommend that EVERY rider invest in a helmet that has this. My neurologist knew of this technology and mentioned that since the advent of MIPS equipped helmets in cycling, motor sports, snow sports and riding there have been dramatic differences in both recovery times and severity of brain trauma. (In a good way)

There are two fabulous videos produced by the MIPS developers that explain very well why MIPS is important and how it works. I would encourage everyone to watch these. They’re not that long, and they aren’t equine specific.

https://vimeo.com/279413370

https://vimeo.com/318457059

At the moment the following brands have helmets with MIPS technology:

Trauma Void - EQ3 and Lynx models

Charles Owen - Theirs are the “MyPs” models (Skull cap and two other designs)

Armis Polo Helmets.

I have sent messages to the Facebook business pages for as many other brands as I could think of asking if they intended to have a MIPS helmet in the future, I have heard back from Samshield (no. Not worth it to them) and Tipperary (yes, model is forthcoming in Feb 2020). I’m still working on getting more answers.

So that’s the whole story.

Hopefully I will get to show again this year, but if not there’s always next year :slight_smile:

Em

Goodness gracious. That sounds scary. Glad to hear it wasn’t more serious. Hope you continue to feel better!

1 Like

Best healing wishes to you!!

1 Like

Glad you’re going to be ok! And thank you for the helmet info.

Horses. :cool: One minute you’re minding your own business and next thing you know, you’re in the ER.

20 Likes

Thank you for sharing that information. I’m so, so sorry that such a freak accident happened to you. I hope you will continue to recover quickly.

3 Likes

How very scary! I know Kymmy Pullen and was wondering what the back and forth comments re: Devon and the ingate were about.

I assume the fact you were there and dressed to show means your horse is fully recovered from the KY trailer incident?

1 Like

Thank you for sharing, and I am so glad you are going to be ok! I bought a Trauma Void helmet, pretty much an impulse buy at Rolex in 2018. I had had a bad fall in show jumping a year before and had a pretty bad concussion. I liked what I saw and heard about the technology so I bought one. After reading what you’ve posted and what your neurologist said, I’m going to buy both of my kids’ one too!

2 Likes

Trailer accident yes. (Not trainer. Love auto correct!)

Yep. He was fine pretty quickly also. We were at his first show after that incident 1 month later and he was great. He was REALLY ready for Devon and ironically he was safe on the trailer while I was being hit by another horse jumping out of a safe place.

The irony is thick.

Em

6 Likes

Thank you so much for sharing your story. The scar is barely noticeable now. Or if anyone comments, you’ll have a heck of a story to tell.

I was was just looking at my Samshield and thinking it was time for a new one. Good for you for becoming an advocate for helmet safety.

3 Likes

Thanks so much for sharing your story! Best wishes for a full and speedy recovery.

1 Like

so glad you are safe

1 Like

Glad you are ok! How is the horse, if you know?

1 Like

I actually do know. He is doing well. He had a number of scrapes and cuts but his owner tells me he is healing up. I am hopeful to get to see her again sometime when we’re all healed up and back out showing.

I cannot with good conscience recommend you to buy another Samshield. I know they’re fancy and pricey and popular but the 2 emails I have from them explaining how their helmet testing did nothing to convince them that the technology was worth the added weight (25 grams, same as 10 pennies) and added cost was just mind blowing. The technology we’re discussing is to help with a human brain and it’s possibility for injuries. As much as I appreciate how far testing devices have come, I feel confident in saying that no testing device can replicate the brain of every rider who might wear one of the helmets and might come off. They’re being extremely short sighted in my view and it’s more entertaining when you consider that Trauma Void is selling helmets for $250 that will protect your brain better than a $400-$800 Samshield. To reiterate, this is my own opinion.

Em

24 Likes

That reminds me of something I heard from my vet many years ago. We played polo together at a very relaxed level with a group of friends. He said he was happy to play in a $300 saddle on a $500 horse that he shipped in a $1000 trailer. But he was going to have the very best helmet money could buy, regardless of the price! Wise man. :slight_smile:

11 Likes

You have single handily convinced me to spring for a Trauma Void helmet. I don’t need a new helmet as I bought one a year ago and have had no falls, but I want to protect my head.

13 Likes

I know this is not a important point in the realm of the helmet portion of your incident, but yes, I can personally attest to how badly head wounds bleed. I got a wound on the temple that they could barely get three stitches in and I was literally covered in blood from the temple to my feet.

2 Likes

You are so lucky to be alive and so glad you are healing and that the horses are okay too. Thank you for the Trauma Void helmet information. I will buy one based on your recommendation. I will let my friends know too. Take care and thank you for posting.

2 Likes

That is insane as the new CO MIPS helmet is priced at about $250, as is the EQ3. It will be the 2nd lowest priced of the CO line, above the JR8. If the technology is so expensive, why are the existing MIPS helmets so reasonably priced?
ETA: I already have an EQ3, and will be trying the MyPS when it becomes available locally.

6 Likes

Em I’m so glad you are ok. That sounds terrifying. I can’t believe you look so good already!!! You’re tough.

Glad you are OK and getting good follow-up care. I have used cycling helmets with MIPS technology for several before the Trauma Void helmet was available. I bought a T.V. as soon as I heard about them (on the Eventing Forum). I am now on my second T.V. since I have always purchased a new helmet every 18-24 months, even if nothing has impacted the helmet. Since I use my brain for my living, I’d rather be safe than sorry.

4 Likes