For the purist dog herder, cutter and penner, cattle, buffalo, sheep, Muscovy ducks, those will herd and so work differently than other species that rather scatter and will kind of herd only under duress, like donkeys, other kind of fowl, goats can fit somewhere in the middle, some will herd, some scatter like wild things.
When your stock doesn’t truly herd, then you are reverting back to chasing, which is fine in some events like penning, just makes the job a bit harder.
The real cutters would not even think of penning, it distracts from cutting one on one and some even think cutters lose focus after penning too much and are not as good a cutter later.
In real ranch work, you would just not “use” your stock as in arena cutting or penning, it is just not done for time, but to get the job done.
Old times would not like it if you took some of their cattle, put them in a pen and “practiced” on them.:eek:
Even out in the pastures, cowboys would be fired if they were caught cutting or roping or in any way chasing stock around “just to train their horse”.:no:
Now, done well, you can practice any you want to do and compete without harm to any livestock, as long as you are well aware of what you are doing, not only hot on the fun part.
Some of our nicer to handle replacement heifers were used gently for cutting practice.
For some years, we used to provide several hundred cattle a year for a big cutting finals event and they were handled very nicely.
What we have to keep reminding all those using stock to practice and compete is that the stock are not horse or dog toys.:no:
Just adding perspective to some of this.