I just spent a very long time trying all the black dress boots (for hunting) available at my local Dover in Jan 2015 and thought I’d share my results here.
First lesson: boots in real life bear no resemblance to the boots pictured online! (another reason not to buy online). As most of you already know, most tall boots look the same online - beautifully shaped and shiny, etc. But in real life, you instantly realize the leather and cut feel and look so different!
I tried on the Tuffriders and Mountain Horses. In real life their leather and cut and up-close details really leave much to be desired. Online they look nice but sadly up close they just look cheap. They’re still charging hundreds of dollars, though, so in my mind it’s not really justifiable.
Then I tried on Tredstep Donatello Dress Boots. I think they are good value for their price, and the leather and cut looks relatively upscale. However, for some inexplicable reason, the part of the boot that wraps around your heel is very hard, so that you feel like there is a cup stuck to your heel and really biting into it. I have the Tredstep Giotto Paddock Boots and there is no similar issue. So it’s not my foot, it’s just a weird design quirk. I would have bought it but for this problem. I’m not sure if it would get softer as you “break it in” but I’m not going to risk hundreds of dollars for something that doesn’t work upfront.
The most expensive line in the store was the Cavallos. Surprisingly, the boot was rock hard. I can’t believe it. It was not supple at all. I have polo boots that are rock hard because (I was told) they’re designed to withstand another player slamming himself and his horse into me (and they have). But really, do equestrian dress boots have to be rock hard? They just feel so uncomfortable, and for that top-of-the-line price, I’m not sure if it’s justified.
Finally, I decided (after trying on everything), that the best dress boot at the store was the Ariat Monaco Stretch Zip Dress Boot. Now, there are at least 2 types of Monacos - this one is the STRETCH one. It’s really soft (so much so that it was the only tall boot in the store that doesn’t stand upright, it flops over) and the inside is lined with a high-tech looking soft webbing material. Just one touch of the leather surface and you fall in love - it’s luxurious and supple and moist. The entire design and cut is very upscale and it looks like it’s worth its price. Even the inside is lined in beautiful cream leather. It’s not the most expensive dress boot in the store, but it’s definitely expensive. However, it was the only one that I felt really justified its price and offered true quality, design, and comfort. The only caveat I have is that I’m not sure how waterproof it is, and since the leather is so soft as to feel delicate, it might scratch or crack after one or two seasons no matter how much you oil it (heartbreak!)
I hope this is helpful. Sorry I did not note down the actual model names when trying things on, but they are the Jan 2015 models that are currently online and in Dover stores, so I hope this gives you a good idea if you are comparison shopping online for dress boots for hunting. They did not have other brands at the store that they had online, so I am not mentioning those.
Lastly, as you all probably already know, a Regular calf in one brand is a Full in another and is a Wide in yet another, so you really just have to try them on in the store rather than trust the online specs. And each brand tends to run large or small, too. Infuriating!
Please share your hunt dress boot shopping stories, I would love to hear the latest.