For a dressage saddle, I would recommend a Schleese.
For a jumping saddle, I would recommend a Schleese.
The best part is that they are right down the road from you, and you’ll be able to get fitted quickly.
Yes, these saddles are expensive, if you buy one new. I have been lucky enough to buy both a jump and a dressage saddle used- they fit me beautifully- and have been repeatedly fit to my horse as he’s muscled and changed. The purchase price of BOTH my Schleese saddles total the investment in building/fitting/refitting/new tree/ more refitting I have in my original custom made saddle. (I won’t mention the saddle maker but he fits US Olympians.) That saddle was just never right for my horse, contantly causing wither pocket pressure, spine pressure, and discomfort. My Schleese saddles, I believe, have saved my horse’s back, and extended his life. And they are incredibly comfy! Go to a local saddle fitting when you can- people come and watch and learn at ones at our barn all the time. You may have a chance to sit in a number of saddles, and see which seat feels goof for you and what size you take. Then the e-bay search can begin…
Good luck!